Opening
Donald Schön frames the preface to Educating the Reflective Practitioner as the culmination of a long “intellectual journey.” He returns to John Dewey’s influence and to observations from M.I.T.’s architectural studios to argue that professional education must move beyond rigid theory toward an artistry practiced in action.
What Happens
Schön positions this book as a sequel to The Reflective Practitioner (1983), where he develops an “epistemology of practice” and critiques the reigning university model he calls Technical Rationality. In that model, competence means applying scientific theory to discrete problems. Schön argues this produces a “dilemma of rigor or relevance,” because it ignores the uncertainty, uniqueness, and value conflicts that define real practice.
As an alternative, he advances Reflection-in-Action—the skilled, improvisational thinking practitioners use while doing the work. This book asks the unresolved question from his earlier work: What kind of professional education fits that epistemology? His answer is The Reflective Practicum: a learning environment that marries applied science with coaching in artistry. He points to “deviant traditions” such as art and design studios, music conservatories, and apprenticeships as live models of Learning by Doing and Coaching. The architectural design studio becomes his primary prototype.
Schön then maps the book. Part Two probes the design studio’s paradoxes and rituals. Part Three traces variations of the practicum in other fields—a master class in performance, psychoanalytic supervision, and a counseling seminar he co-teaches with Chris Argyris—to illustrate coaching styles he labels “Follow me!,” “joint experimentation,” and “hall of mirrors.” Part Four pushes toward reform, arguing that redesigning professional education is overdue. He promises not just successes but “horrible examples” of coaching gone wrong, and he defines his audience—educators, practitioners, and students—presenting the book as a “primer” meant to invite further inquiry into professional competence and artistry.
Character Development
Schön casts himself less as an authority and more as a guide, narrating how his ideas grow from Deweyan philosophy and years embedded in studio pedagogy. He writes as a coach inviting readers into a shared investigation rather than delivering a closed doctrine.
-
Donald Schön
- Reconnects Dewey’s pragmatism to contemporary professional education.
- Builds authority through field observation, not just theory.
- Adopts a collaborative “primer” stance to spur experimentation.
-
Chris Argyris
- Appears as Schön’s teaching partner in the counseling seminar, foreshadowing the book’s attention to interpersonal dynamics and organizational learning.
- His collaboration becomes a key case in Chapter 9-10 Summary, exemplifying a reflective practicum in action.
Themes & Symbols
Schön’s preface sets up a clash between the dominant academic model and the lived realities of practice. Technical Rationality seeks certainty and control; practice presents ambiguity, conflict, and surprise. Reflection-in-action reframes expertise as a kind of real-time inquiry: practitioners make moves, observe consequences, reframe problems, and try again. Education, therefore, must cultivate this disciplined improvisation, not merely deliver rules to be applied.
This reorientation recasts competence as an interplay of head and hand—Professional Artistry vs. Technical Skill. Technical skill matters, but without artistry—the capacity to perceive situations, name what is going on, try novel responses, and learn in the moment—professionals falter in the messy world outside the lab. The design studio functions as a symbol for this synthesis: a space where students learn by doing, receive critiques, and reflect out loud with a coach, modeling the very habits Schön wants across professions.
Key Quotes
“An intellectual journey.”
- The phrase grounds a theoretical argument in lived experience. Schön’s credibility rests not only on analysis but on a decade-plus of observation and reflection that mirrors the very practice he advocates.
“Dilemma of rigor or relevance.”
- This formulation names the central institutional bind: methods prized by the academy often miss the texture of practice. The book sets out to dissolve this false choice by redefining what counts as rigorous.
“Epistemology of practice.”
- Schön reframes knowing as something enacted, situated, and revisable. The term signals a shift from knowledge as static theory to knowledge as reflective performance under real constraints.
“Reflection-in-Action.”
- This is the engine of expert practice: thinking while doing. It captures how practitioners diagnose, experiment, and learn in the midst of action rather than after the fact.
“The Reflective Practicum.”
- The proposed solution translates the epistemology into pedagogy. Studios, conservatories, and apprenticeships become models where coaching, feedback, and iterative making are core.
“Follow me!”, “joint experimentation,” and “hall of mirrors.”
- These labels map distinct coaching styles—from modeling to co-inquiry to reflective feedback loops—offering a vocabulary for designing and critiquing learning environments.
“Horrible examples.”
- By promising failures as well as successes, Schön underscores that reflective pedagogy requires discernment; not all coaching cultivates artistry.
“A primer.”
- The modesty calibrates expectations and invites adoption. Schön seeks to open a field of practice, not to close debate.
Why This Matters and Section Significance
The preface serves as both manifesto and blueprint. It frames why conventional professional education falls short and introduces a concrete alternative—the reflective practicum—rooted in live coaching, iterative making, and disciplined reflection. By previewing the design studio and cross-field cases, Schön sets a trajectory from critique to models to reform.
This positioning matters for the rest of the book: every chapter applies the preface’s terms—Technical Rationality, reflection-in-action, reflective practicum—to real classrooms and studios. The preface equips readers with a shared language and a map, turning the book into a guided tour of how professional artistry can be taught, coached, and sustained.