Forbidden and Fated Love
This theme explores the intoxicating yet agonizing paradox of a love that is both destined and damned. It delves into questions of whether true love can transcend time and fate, or if some connections are inherently doomed. The narrative grapples with the tension between free will and predestination, asking if characters can defy a cosmic plan or if they are merely puppets of destiny. Ultimately, it examines the sacrifices one is willing to make for love, even when that love is a source of profound suffering.
How It Develops
The theme of forbidden and fated love is established immediately and intensifies as the story unfolds. The prologue introduces the tragic cycle of Luce and Daniel's relationship, setting the stage for their destined yet doomed connection. As Luce arrives at Sword & Cross, her inexplicable attraction to Daniel highlights the fated aspect of their bond, while Daniel's hostility underscores the forbidden nature of their love. Their interactions become a dance between destiny and free will, with moments of intense connection followed by deliberate attempts at separation. The climax arrives when Daniel reveals the truth about their past lives and the curse that condemns them to repeat this tragic pattern, solidifying the central conflict of their love.
Key moments illustrating this development:
- Prologue (1854): Daniel's desperate plea, "If I leave, I save your life," immediately establishes the deadly consequences of their love. Despite his efforts, their connection leads to her death, showcasing the tragic paradox at the heart of their relationship.
- Arrival at Sword & Cross: Luce's immediate and overwhelming attraction to Daniel, despite his cold demeanor, exemplifies the irresistible pull of their fated connection.
- The Lake Scene: Daniel's admission that he's been "burned before" hints at their shared history and the pain of past lives, adding depth to the forbidden aspect of their love.
- The Kiss on the Beach: Daniel's shocked reaction ("You're still here") after their kiss confirms that their love defies the rules of the curse, highlighting the danger inherent in their connection.
Key Examples
Specific scenes emphasize the dual nature of Luce and Daniel's relationship, where destiny and danger intertwine.
-
Luce's Instant Recognition: Upon seeing Daniel, Luce experiences an inexplicable déjà vu, a clear sign of their fated bond.
When Daniel’s eyes held hers, her breath caught in her throat. She recognized him from somewhere. But she would have remembered meeting someone like him. She would have remembered feeling as absolutely shaken up as she did right now.
This instant recognition underscores the idea that their connection transcends time and memory, suggesting a love that is written in the stars.
-
Daniel's Attempt to Repel Luce: Daniel's infamous gesture is a desperate attempt to sever their fated connection before it can become deadly. By trying to make Luce hate him, he hopes to protect her from the curse.
-
Daniel's Confession: The climax of the novel is Daniel's explanation of their eternal, tragic love affair, which explicitly defines the theme.
“The person I fall in love with each time is you.”... “And every time we meet, you fall for me—” “I can resist you or flee from you or try my hardest not to respond to you, but it makes no difference. You fall in love with me, and I with you.” “Is that so terrible?” “And it kills you.”
This confession reveals the full extent of their tragic fate, highlighting the immense sacrifice and suffering that their love entails.
Character Connections
The main characters embody different facets of the forbidden and fated love theme.
- Lucinda "Luce" Price: Luce embodies the fated aspect of their love. In each life, she is drawn to Daniel, regardless of circumstance or memory. Her journey is one of discovering the cosmic forces that bind them together.
- Daniel Grigori: Daniel represents the forbidden aspect, burdened by the knowledge of their past and the curse that threatens Luce. He actively tries to push her away, torn between his love and his desire to protect her.
- Cameron "Cam" Briel: Cam serves as an antagonist to their fated love, offering Luce an alternative that seems safer and more accessible. His presence highlights the external forces working to keep Luce and Daniel apart.
Symbolism
Symbols throughout the novel reinforce the theme of forbidden and fated love.
- The Sword & Cross School: The reform school setting symbolizes the confinement and restrictions placed on Luce and Daniel's love. The school's name reflects the violent, holy war that serves as the backdrop for their romance.
- The Cemetery: As a place of death and remembrance, the cemetery symbolizes the tragic history of Luce and Daniel's love. It is the setting for pivotal moments, linking their romance to mortality and recurring loss.
- Daniel's Sketches: Daniel's compulsion to draw Luce in every lifetime symbolizes the enduring, fated nature of his love. The sketches are a tangible record of his eternal memory and affection.
Through the theme of forbidden and fated love, Lauren Kate explores the power and limitations of destiny. The novel suggests that true love can transcend time and death, but it also acknowledges the immense sacrifices and obstacles that such love entails. The story champions the idea that love is not passive but an active struggle, requiring characters to fight against the forces that forbid it.
Contemporary Relevance
The theme of forbidden and fated love continues to resonate with modern audiences, tapping into the enduring appeal of soulmate narratives. The idea that a connection can be so profound it feels predestined is a popular trope in contemporary romance literature and media. The "forbidden" aspect also speaks to the universal experience of facing obstacles in a relationship, whether due to social pressures or personal challenges. The story of Luce and Daniel is an exaggerated version of the classic "star-crossed lovers" trope, capturing the intensity of first love and the feeling that one's relationship is the most important story in the world.