What This Theme Explores
Love and Romance in Love & Gelato asks how first love becomes lasting love—and how to tell the difference between infatuation and a relationship grounded in trust, honesty, and shared joy. The novel braids two stories: [Lina Emerson]’s present-tense awakening and the recovered past of her mother, [Hadley Emerson], whose journals model both mistake and wisdom. As Lina’s bond with [Lorenzo "Ren" Ferrara] ripens from banter into tenderness, the book probes whether real love heals, expands one’s life, and encourages self-knowledge. It ultimately contends that the sweetest romances are slow-grown: partnerships that begin in friendship and mature into devotion.
How It Develops
When Lina arrives in Italy, romance is an archive rather than a possibility—something that happened to her mother and now lives in a journal. Grief keeps her guarded; Ren is a friendly ally, while her crush on Thomas offers a glossy, low-stakes fantasy. Love, at this stage, is a puzzle of someone else’s past and a safe daydream of her own.
As Lina reads further, Hadley’s pages complicate the picture: the breathless pull toward [Matteo Rossi] contrasts with the quiet steadiness of [Howard Mercer]. Simultaneously, Lina’s dynamic with Ren shifts from inside jokes and wandering Florence to deliberate trust, as she risks sharing the journal and, by extension, her heart. The parallels invite Lina to separate spark from substance—recognizing that intensity without integrity burns out, while affection rooted in respect grows steadier.
By the end, the journal’s truth is clear: Hadley’s truest love was Howard, a connection born in friendship but imperiled by secrecy. Lina breaks that cycle—choosing honesty, choosing the boy who has already been a partner in her healing, and choosing a love that feels like belonging. The novel closes on a hopeful echo: where Hadley lost time to silence, Lina and Ren begin with confession and care.
Key Examples
-
Hadley’s Journal Entries: Early entries surge with the rush of clandestine passion, capturing the exhilaration of falling fast.
I’m sure it will come as no surprise when I say that I’ve fallen in L-O-V-E. What a cliché! But seriously, move to Florence and eat a few forkfuls of pasta, then stroll in the twilight and just TRY not to fall for that guy you’ve been ogling from day one! Later, the tone shifts to serenity and choice, recasting love as daily devotion rather than drama. I thought I wanted caprice and fire, but it turns out that what I really want is someone who will wake me up early so I don’t miss a sunrise. What I really want is Howard. And now I have him. The juxtaposition traces the book’s thesis: passion dazzles, but partnership endures.
-
Lina and Ren at the Ponte Vecchio: Ren brings Lina to a place her mother loved, and she entrusts him with the journal, knitting past and present into one shared story. Their vulnerability at this bridge turns friendship into intimacy, modeling how trust is the engine of romance. The scene’s intergenerational resonance deepens their bond, as detailed in the Chapter 11-15 Summary.
-
The Party at Valentina’s: Lina attends with Thomas, but spends the evening scanning for Ren—evidence that attention follows attachment, not appearances. Jealousy and misunderstanding spur an honest confrontation, pushing both teens to name what they feel. The fallout dissolves the illusion of the crush and clarifies the solidity of the friendship-turned-romance.
-
The Final Scene at the Cemetery: Ren’s apology—coins at the window, a cornetta con Nutella from the secret bakery—speaks in the language of Lina’s journey with her mother. In the quiet of the cemetery, they trade secrets for truth and infatuation for intention. Their confession inaugurates a relationship defined by candor and care, a healing counterpoint to Hadley’s thwarted love.
Character Connections
Lina Emerson: Lina’s arc moves from guarded grief to openhearted risk, learning love first by reading and then by choosing. Her early fixation on Thomas is romance-as-storybook, while her trust in Ren is romance-as-practice: listening, showing up, and letting herself be seen. By privileging steadiness over spectacle, she writes a different ending than her mother’s.
Hadley Emerson: Hadley embodies the theme’s central dichotomy. With Matteo, she experiences the intoxicating highs and corrosive power imbalances of secrecy; with Howard, she discovers the restorative quiet of a love that notices sunrises and keeps promises. Her story becomes both warning and compass for her daughter.
Lorenzo "Ren" Ferrara: Ren models healthy attachment—playful, patient, and reliably present. He invites Lina into Florence and into herself, translating curiosity into care. His instinct to apologize and to listen marks him as a partner, not a provocateur.
Howard Mercer: Howard represents steadfast, selfless love—faithful across years, gentle but resolute. His restraint, even when it costs him, reframes romance as an ethic of responsibility and kindness. He is the novel’s north star for what enduring love looks like.
Matteo Rossi: Matteo is the cautionary figure: a charisma that eclipses conscience. His secrecy and control expose how passion, absent respect, becomes possessive and destructive. Through him, the novel teaches discernment—chemistry isn’t character.
Symbolic Elements
-
Hadley’s Journal: More than a clue-box, the journal is a living legacy—mapping both Florence and the heart’s detours. As Lina reads, she inherits not just stories but standards, learning to choose the kind of love the pages ultimately endorse.
-
Gelato: Sweet and simple, gelato embodies love’s everyday delights. The shared taste of bacio connects Lina to Hadley and Howard, suggesting that intimacy is often built through small, joyful rituals.
-
The Ring: Howard’s antique ring testifies to constancy across distance and time. Worn by Hadley and later by Lina, it becomes a conduit of blessing—a tangible reminder to prefer devotion over drama.
-
The Tower: The sunrise kiss atop the old stone tower sanctifies Hadley and Howard’s private truth. Elevated above the city’s chaos, it symbolizes a love anchored in quiet beauty rather than spectacle.
Contemporary Relevance
In a world of curated feeds and instant crushes, the novel’s insistence on friendship-first romance feels refreshingly countercultural. It arms readers with criteria—honesty, reciprocity, steadiness—to evaluate relationships beyond surface chemistry. By dramatizing a toxic dynamic alongside a healthy one, it offers a blueprint for recognizing manipulation and choosing care, making its insights as practical as they are poetic.
Essential Quote
I thought I wanted caprice and fire, but it turns out that what I really want is someone who will wake me up early so I don’t miss a sunrise. What I really want is Howard. And now I have him.
Hadley’s admission reframes love as a series of gentle, intentional acts, not a spectacle of grand gestures. It crystallizes the book’s argument that attention and reliability are more romantic—and more transformative—than volatility. In claiming what she truly wants, Hadley names the standard Lina learns to choose.