Opening
A winter confession cracks open the hidden heart of the house: a nurse whispers her betrayal into the frozen earth, and decades later a fraudulent medium summons a truth she never intends to touch. Together, these chapters braid love, guilt, and land into a single haunt, where human secrets echo—and the oldest voice belongs to the orchard.
What Happens
Chapter 5
In the winter after the death of William Henry Teale, his unnamed nurse cannot bear the silence of the house they share. Unable to find a living confidant, she walks into the woods, digs into the frozen ground, and tells the earth everything—his secret and hers. Her confession unfolds as a long memory: she arrives at fifty-four to care for the seventy-five-year-old painter after his broken leg, finds the house neglected and crowded with bones, nests, stones, and fungi, and slowly becomes indispensable. She organizes his chaos, coaxes him outside—pushing him by sleigh to the meadow—and restores his appetite for the world.
As seasons turn, their intimacy deepens through walks and quiet work. He reveals his “melancholy,” a past suicide attempt, the story of a wife who left him, and finally his paintings of the Azores—her homeland—like fate reaching back to greet them. Feeling she has “repaired” him, she buys him new paints; he begins to create again. Their love never becomes explicit, but it grows into a devoted domestic partnership that embodies Love, Loneliness, and Connection.
Then she discovers a hidden bundle of letters to E.N.—Erasmus Nash—and learns that William’s “melancholy” comes not from a failed marriage but from the loss of his true love. Shortly after, a new letter arrives: Erasmus accepts a visit. Terrified of being replaced and losing the life she builds, she tears the note to shreds and burns it. William dies believing his friend never replies. Now, kneeling in the snow, she entrusts the truth to the soil itself, preserving his public story while begging private forgiveness and exposing The Nature of Storytelling and Truth.
Chapter 6
In the early 20th century, Karl and Emily Farnsworth own the house. Karl, a wealthy industrialist, remakes it as “The Catamount Lodge,” a trophy retreat crammed with taxidermy; he clears the old apple orchard to make his sportsman’s paradise, exemplifying Human Impact on the Environment. The narrator is Anastasia Rossi, a charismatic spiritualist who openly works as a fraud. Hired to resolve Emily’s haunting, she learns that Emily hears two men—a painter and a poet—making “vile, vile psalmody,” laughter and sighs and love-poems: the house still holds the voices of William and Erasmus, proof of The Persistence of History and Memory.
Anastasia suspects psychological distress rather than spirits, reading the marriage as poisonous and Emily’s perceptions as shaped by Mental Illness and Perception. Karl calls his wife “crazy,” then turns on Anastasia as a cheat. Their argument flashes into desire; they begin a rough affair while Emily lies upstairs. Anastasia frames the liaison as fieldwork—a way to map the house’s power before the performance of a séance.
At the séance, her usual tricks are interrupted by the impossible: two lambent lights appear, play, and vanish. Terrified, she feels a greater force seize her; a “brash, irate, and martial” voice surges through. The message does not belong to the painter or the poet. It thunders: “He asks... what you have done to his apple trees.” The presence is not William. It is Charles Osgood, the first settler, raging over the destruction of his orchard—an older claim rising to judge the living.
Character Development
The section reveals intimate, often contradictory motives: tenderness that curdles into betrayal, skepticism that collides with the sublime, and power that masks fear.
-
The Nurse
- Finds purpose in care and companionship; her identity shifts from “temporary assistance” to indispensable partner.
- Acts out of love and terror, burning Erasmus’s letter to protect the life she builds.
- Confesses to the land, seeking absolution no human can grant.
-
- Emerges as an artist sustained by nature and undone by a hidden love.
- His supposed marital tragedy is reframed by letters to Erasmus, recasting his retreat as Sanctuary and Escape.
- Resumes painting when given tools and care, revealing how connection rekindles creativity.
-
Anastasia Rossi
- A keen reader of people who treats belief as theatre, until the supernatural forces her to confront a reality beyond her control.
- Uses seduction as leverage, then becomes an instrument for a voice she cannot script.
-
Karl Farnsworth
- Treats land, animals, and people as possessions—clearing orchards, mounting trophies, taking a lover.
- Masks insecurity with bluster; his domination of nature mirrors his marital cruelty.
-
Emily Farnsworth
- Dismissed as “hysterical,” yet her hearing of lovers is accurate to the house’s past.
- Becomes an unwilling medium whose sensitivity exposes the emotional residue of the place.
Themes & Symbols
Both chapters insist that stories endure—not because humans tell them well, but because places remember. The nurse curates a gentle public narrative and buries a harsher one, while Anastasia sells fictions and is overtaken by an older truth. Memory adheres to rooms, boards, and orchards; lovers’ whispers drift through time, yet the land’s grievance roars loudest.
The treatment of nature divides eras and ethics. William studies nests and bones with reverence; Karl displays taxidermy as conquest and razes an “unprofitable” orchard. Emotional damage and ecological damage align: to sever roots is to stir ghosts. Love offers repair, but fear of loss contorts into harm. The book asks who may tell a “true” story and whether confession, performance, or madness carries the deeper truth.
Symbols:
- The Earth: The nurse’s confessional—mute, impartial, capacious—holds love, guilt, and truth when no human witness can.
- The Apple Trees: A living archive of origin and cultivation; their erasure summons the founding voice to demand restitution.
- Taxidermied Animals: Nature arrested and displayed as property, a stark counterpoint to William’s living studies.
Key Quotes
“vile, vile psalmody”
- Emily’s phrase collapses reverence and revulsion, turning sacred song into a sneer for queer intimacy. It signals both her pain and uncanny accuracy about the house’s past, where love poetry and touch once filled the rooms.
“temporary assistance”
- The nurse’s initial status names a boundary that dissolves. What begins as a job becomes devotion—and then control—showing how care can slide into possession when love fears its own fragility.
“repaired”
- Her claim that she has “repaired” William reveals pride and tenderness, but also a dangerous entitlement. Believing she fixes him, she assumes a right to protect the life they share at any cost, even by burning Erasmus’s letter.
“He asks... what you have done to his apple trees.”
- The séance strips away recent scandals to foreground an older jurisdiction: the land’s first cultivator. The question reframes haunting as stewardship—the most grievous trespass is environmental, not erotic.
Why This Matters and Section Significance
These chapters pivot the novel from intimate confession to gothic spectacle while widening its moral frame. Chapter 5 closes William’s story with the revelation that a life can be both redeemed and deformed by love; Chapter 6 confronts the modern appetite to own and display, exposing how conquest—of bodies, stories, and land—summons judgment. By ending with Charles Osgood’s fury, the book asserts a hierarchy of memory: human passion lingers, but the land’s memory—and its claim—endures longest.