Truth, Lies, and Deception
What This Theme Explores
Truth in November 9 is never simply the opposite of a lie; it’s a spectrum that ranges from deliberate falsehoods to omissions, performances, and self-deception. The novel asks whether a love born in performance can survive when the curtain finally drops—whether intimacy requires not just affection but the courage to reveal what could destroy it. By placing Fallon O'Neil and Benton James Kessler inside an arrangement that invites both candor and concealment, the story probes the ethics of “protective” lies. Ultimately, it contends that connection collapses without honesty, and that the brutal truth, however devastating, is the only ground sturdy enough to build upon.
How It Develops
The first November 9 introduces truth as performance. Ben’s improvised rescue at Fallon’s lunch with her father, Donovan O'Neil, is a lie with benevolent aims—a mask worn to buffer her from humiliation. It charms because it so neatly fixes a problem, yet it also plants the seed that deception can be romantic, even heroic. What neither Fallon nor the reader sees yet is the larger performance: Ben’s “coincidental” arrival is staged.
A year later, the lies become quieter and more corrosive. Omissions—and the rationalizations that justify them—replace bold inventions. Ben hides the true nature of the rift with his brother, Kyle Kessler, while he and Fallon hide from themselves how deep their attachment runs. The rules of their annual arrangement serve as a refuge from vulnerability, allowing them to pretend boundaries are enough to keep the truth at bay.
By the third meeting, deception turns active and wounding. Overwhelmed by grief and guilt tied to the fire, Ben tells Fallon that Kyle has died, an invention meant to avoid the pain of seeing her. In response, Fallon tells her own “protective” lie—claiming she doesn’t want to be with him—to shield his family and herself from conflict. Each lie intends to soften impact, yet together they rupture trust.
The fallout intensifies in the fourth year. Ben is now with Jordyn, a life that grows in the void created by secrecy. His public confession of love is a cathartic burst of truth, but it emerges inside a web spun from years of concealment—an admission that arrives late, and at a cost to everyone entangled.
In the fifth year, the story’s foundational lie detonates. Fallon discovers Ben’s manuscript and learns the truth of the fire that marked her life and body. What had seemed like serendipity collapses into design; their romance, it turns out, has been curated by a secret Ben could not bear to face aloud.
Only in the sixth November 9 does the novel propose a path through the wreckage: unvarnished, complete truth. Ben gives Fallon the full manuscript—the context, the motives, the shame—handing over not a defense but accountability. In telling everything, he relinquishes control of the narrative, and the possibility of forgiveness appears precisely because he stops trying to manage the truth.
Key Examples
The novel punctuates its arc with scenes that dramatize the dangerous convenience of deception and the liberating violence of confession.
-
The “Fake Boyfriend” Ruse (in the first few chapters): Ben slides into Fallon’s booth, pretending to be her boyfriend to defuse a humiliating lunch. The lie dazzles because it protects her, teaching both Fallon and the reader to associate deception with intimacy and safety. That initial charm becomes the template for later lies that feel loving in the moment but accumulate long-term harm.
“Sorry I’m late, babe,” he says, wrapping his arm around my shoulders. ... “Just go with it,” he whispers.
-
Fallon’s Protective Lies: When a waiter gushes about Donovan, Fallon fabricates a glowing response. This social lie highlights how performance can mask pain—and how easily the world rewards palatable fictions. Her practiced smile foreshadows the self-deception she will later use to avoid facing the full implications of Ben’s secrecy.
Just when I think she’s about to roll her eyes, she releases a pent-up breath and smiles. “It was absolutely surreal. I’m the luckiest daughter in the world.”
-
The Lie About Kyle’s Death: On the third November 9, Ben tells Fallon that Kyle has died to avoid meeting her. The lie is a shield against grief that becomes a weapon against trust; it confuses what pain should be shared with what must be hidden. By co-opting tragedy, Ben teaches Fallon that nothing in their relationship can be assumed real without proof.
-
The Manuscript’s Revelation (in the final chapters): Fallon learns from Ben’s prologue that he started the fire that scarred her. The manuscript, once a romantic artifact, flips into an archive of accountability, proof that stories can either obscure or illuminate reality. The shift from mythmaking to confession reframes every earlier November 9 as a step toward an unavoidable reckoning.
November 9th. The night I intentionally started the fire that almost claimed the life of the girl who would one day save mine.
Character Connections
Ben is the architect of the central deception, and his arc traces the moral cost of “protective” secrecy. He convinces himself that omitting the truth safeguards Fallon’s healing, transforming love into a management project. His eventual surrender to full disclosure acknowledges that intimacy cannot be curated; it requires the risk that telling the truth may end the relationship it seeks to honor.
Fallon is both victim and participant. Her belief that her scars make her unlovable primes her to accept partial truths and to perform composure for others. When she lies to push Ben away, she mirrors his logic—harm now to prevent harm later—and learns, through betrayal, that self-worth and trust are inseparable from demanding the whole truth.
Donovan models casual, self-serving dishonesty—the performance of care when it benefits him. His behavior normalizes the idea that appearances can replace accountability, shaping Fallon’s early acquiescence to pleasant fictions and underscoring the cultural backdrop against which the lovers negotiate truth.
Kyle, the reluctant keeper of Ben’s secret, acts as moral ballast. His anger is not merely punitive; it represents the ethical reality that some truths, if buried, rot everything around them. Through Kyle, the novel articulates the line between regret and responsibility: grief is human, but concealment is a choice.
Jordyn embodies the collateral damage of deception. Her relationship with Ben isn’t a plot detour but a consequence, showing how lies radiate outward, entangling those who never consented to the performance. She forces Ben to confront that truth-telling isn’t just about Fallon; it’s about everyone affected by his silence.
Symbolic Elements
The Manuscript: Ben’s novel, also titled November 9, functions first as a mask—curating a love story that omits its darkest origin—then as a mirror that reflects the whole, ugly truth. As an object, it dramatizes the power of narrative to either seduce or set free, depending on whether it conceals or confesses.
The Scars: Fallon’s scars are a visible record of a truth she doesn’t yet possess. They embody the paradox of trauma that is seen but not understood, shaping her identity and fueling both her self-doubt and Ben’s shame until the story behind them is spoken aloud.
November 9th: The date operates like a ritual of reckoning. Each year marks a cycle of performance and revelation, transforming the calendar into a moral metronome that measures how long truth can be postponed—and how high the price grows when it is.
Contemporary Relevance
In a culture saturated with curated feeds and carefully managed personas, November 9 reads like a caution: stories we tell about ourselves can protect in the short term and corrode over time. “Protective” lies, ghosted truths, and strategic omissions may preserve appearances, but they hollow trust—online and off. The novel argues for radical accountability: that owning the full story, including motive and harm, is the only way to repair what deception breaks. Its central question—what kind of truth can love survive?—feels urgent in an age that rewards polish over honesty.
Essential Quote
November 9th. The night I intentionally started the fire that almost claimed the life of the girl who would one day save mine.
This confession collapses the novel’s timelines of romance and remorse into a single, devastating truth. It reframes every earlier act of charm as camouflage and every tender moment as occurring under the shadow of an unspoken crime. By naming the unnameable, the line initiates the possibility of real love—one built not on fantasy, but on truth strong enough to face its own ruin.