What This Theme Explores
Rock Paper Scissors delves into the complex interplay between truth, fiction, and storytelling, suggesting that reality is not a fixed entity but a subjective construct shaped by the narratives we create. The novel explores how easily perception can be manipulated through carefully crafted stories, and how these narratives can serve as tools for deception, revenge, or even self-preservation. It questions the nature of objective truth, suggesting that personal narratives and memories are often unreliable, rewritten to suit individual needs and desires. Ultimately, the novel examines how the stories we tell ourselves and others define our identities and shape our understanding of the world.
How It Develops
The theme of truth, fiction, and storytelling evolves throughout the novel, starting as a subtle undercurrent and building to a crescendo where the very fabric of the narrative is revealed to be a carefully constructed illusion. Initially, the theme is introduced through Adam Wright's profession as a screenwriter, highlighting the act of reshaping stories. The introduction of the anniversary letters, presented as a truthful account of a marriage, further complicates the narrative, blurring the lines between reality and fabrication.
As Adam and Amelia Wright arrive at Blackwater Chapel, the atmosphere intensifies, and the line between their real-life marital crisis and a fictional horror story becomes increasingly blurred. The creepy setting, coupled with the mysterious pamphlet detailing local legends, creates a sense of unease, making it difficult to discern what is real and what is a product of carefully crafted storytelling. Adam's recurring nightmares, which Amelia meticulously documents, add another layer of complexity, presenting a fragmented and unreliable version of his past.
The climax of the novel shatters the illusion, revealing that nearly every narrative thread has been deliberately manipulated. The anniversary letters, initially perceived as Amelia's private chronicle, are revealed to be a fiction crafted by Robin. Amelia has lived a fictional identity her entire adult life, and Adam's story about his mother's death is a lie he tells himself. The book's structure itself becomes the ultimate act of storytelling, designed to mislead the reader until the final pages.
Key Examples
Specific moments and devices throughout the novel highlight the constant interplay between what is real and what is constructed.
-
Adam's Profession: Adam's job as a screenwriter is a constant reminder of the theme. He adapts existing fiction, turning "novels into films or TV shows, like wine into water," reflecting the novel's own process of reshaping and retelling narratives. His frustration with the industry's lack of interest in originality mirrors his own inability to face the original, true story of his past.
-
The Anniversary Letters: The letters are the most significant example of storytelling as deception. Presented as Amelia's private chronicle, they are actually a fiction crafted by Robin to manipulate the reader's perception and frame the narrative for her revenge. The letter for their first anniversary, "Rock," establishes this device:
Your dark and twisted love story about a man who writes a letter to his wife every year on their anniversary, even after she dies, has inspired me to start writing some letters of my own. To you. Once a year.
This passage is deeply ironic, as it is Robin, not Amelia, who is inspired by Adam's screenplay. The letters become the ultimate unreliable narrator, a story masquerading as a confession.
-
Adam's Nightmares: Adam's recurring dream of the "woman in the red kimono" is a story his mind has created to protect him from a traumatic memory. Amelia's role in documenting these dreams is a form of narrative control. She writes down his version of the story, not to help him find the truth, but to ensure he never remembers his own role in the tragedy.
-
The "History of Blackwater Chapel" Pamphlet: This document, found in the crypt, is a piece of deliberate storytelling. It blends historical fact with local ghost stories and urban legends to create an atmosphere of fear. It is a story designed to influence the characters' experience of the place, much like Robin is manipulating their entire weekend.
Character Connections
Each main character is deeply enmeshed in the act of creating, hiding, or manipulating narratives.
-
Adam Wright: As a screenwriter, Adam lives in a world of fiction, preferring the stories in books to the complexities of his own life. He is the unreliable narrator of his own past, having constructed a false memory of his mother's death to absolve himself of guilt. His life is a story he has rewritten to make himself the victim rather than the cause.
-
Robin: Robin is the master storyteller and narrator of the novel. She seizes control of every narrative: she finishes and publishes her father's novels, she writes the anniversary letters that form the backbone of the book, and she orchestrates the weekend in Scotland as a real-life thriller. Her actions are a powerful demonstration of using storytelling to reclaim one's own story and exact revenge.
-
Amelia Wright: Amelia's entire identity is a fiction. She has fabricated a new life to escape her past and atone for her role in the death of Adam's Mother. She manipulates Adam by carefully managing the story of his trauma, ensuring her own secret remains buried.
-
Henry Winter: The reclusive author is a man who built his life around storytelling. He uses fabricated ghost stories about the chapel to protect his privacy, creating a fictional narrative to control his reality. After his death, his entire literary identity becomes a story continued by Robin, making his legacy itself a piece of fiction.
Symbolic Elements
Objects and settings in the novel serve as powerful symbols for the theme of truth, fiction, and storytelling.
-
Blackwater Chapel: The setting is described as "ONE PLACE. MANY STORIES." As a converted chapel, its original purpose—its first story—has been rewritten. It functions less as a home and more as a stage or film set for Robin's elaborate, real-life narrative, blurring the line between a physical place and a fictional construct.
-
The Anniversary Letters: These letters are the primary symbol of manipulated truth. They represent a narrative presented as a factual, intimate account of a marriage, which is ultimately revealed to be a fiction constructed for an audience (the reader) by a hidden author (Robin).
-
Adam's Screenplay, Rock Paper Scissors: This fictional story within the novel is the catalyst for the "real" anniversary letters, creating a meta-fictional loop where one story gives birth to another. The title itself symbolizes the game of chance, choice, and bluff inherent in both relationships and storytelling.
Contemporary Relevance
The theme of truth, fiction, and storytelling resonates powerfully in the contemporary world, an era often defined by "alternative facts," curated online identities, and the struggle to discern truth from misinformation. Rock Paper Scissors explores the ease with which individuals can be manipulated by a compelling narrative, a concept highly relevant in the age of social media and political polarization. The characters' construction of entirely new identities and their rewriting of personal histories mirror the way people curate their own stories online. The novel serves as a cautionary tale about taking any narrative at face value and highlights the essential, and increasingly difficult, human task of separating the stories we are told from the truth we must find for ourselves.
Essential Quote
People believe what they want to believe.
This quote encapsulates the novel's central theme, highlighting the subjective nature of truth and the power of storytelling to shape perception. It suggests that individuals are often more inclined to accept narratives that align with their existing beliefs and desires, regardless of their veracity. This willingness to believe what one wants to believe makes individuals susceptible to manipulation and reinforces the idea that truth is not an objective reality but a construct shaped by individual biases and the stories they choose to embrace.