What This Theme Explores
Love, Marriage, and Infidelity in Jodi Picoult’s The Book of Two Ways probes the difference between comfort and passion, and the cost of confusing safety with truth. The novel asks whether fidelity is merely physical exclusivity or a deeper allegiance to one’s authentic self—what happens when the heart cleaves in two directions at once. It scrutinizes the quiet betrayals partners perform in thought and feeling, and the ache of “what if” that lingers when a life path is chosen. Most provocatively, it wonders whether the gravest infidelity is the one committed against oneself by refusing the life that feels most alive.
How It Develops
The story opens by yoking love to mortality: in the Prologue, a near-death moment makes Dawn Edelstein think not of her husband, Brian Edelstein, or their daughter, but of Wyatt Armstrong—a shock that reframes marriage as a choice that might have eclipsed another, deeper claim on her heart. From there, the novel’s split structure—“Water/Boston” and “Land/Egypt”—juxtaposes Dawn’s stable but strained present with Brian against the intimate, intellectually electric past with Wyatt. The dual timelines keep the question of fidelity suspended between memory and daily life, desire and duty.
As the Boston chapters reveal Brian’s emotional lapse with a colleague, the marriage’s bedrock begins to crack—not solely because of a boundary crossed, but because it exposes how easily attention, loyalty, and imagination can drift. In Egypt, Dawn’s reunion with Wyatt revives a self she buried: the scholar, lover, and partner to a shared vocation. The introduction of Winifred 'Win' Morse, a dying client whose own unresolved first love mirrors Dawn’s, presses the theme further; her story forces Dawn to acknowledge the pull of Regret and Unfinished Business not as nostalgia, but as a claim to a life unlived.
The theme tightens into crisis when Dawn learns that Meret Edelstein is biologically Wyatt’s child. In a single revelation, an emotional “what if” becomes a permanent fact that reorders every bond among Dawn, Brian, and Wyatt. The novel resists tidy resolution: rather than endorsing one love as correct, it insists on the legitimacy of multiple kinds of devotion—and on the losses that attend any choice.
Key Examples
-
The Plane Crash Revelation: In the opening emergency, Dawn’s mind leaps to Wyatt rather than to Brian or Meret. This involuntary turn exposes a long-buried emotional allegiance and reframes the marriage as haunted by a love that never concluded, only paused.
-
Brian’s Emotional Affair: Brian’s closeness with a postdoc never becomes physical, yet it diverts time, attention, and intimacy—most painfully when he misses Meret’s birthday. The lingering scent of roses on his clothes becomes a sensory marker of trust breached, proving that emotional straying can destabilize a marriage as surely as an affair.
-
Win’s Parallel Story: Win confesses that her happy marriage coexisted with an enduring devotion to a first love, asking Dawn if someone “got away.” By making Dawn answer that question for herself, Win converts abstract empathy into action, showing how unresolved love reshapes the choices one allows—or denies—oneself.
-
The Paternity of Meret: The DNA test revealing Wyatt as Meret’s father collapses past and present into one inescapable reality. This fact doesn’t simply expose infidelity; it proves Dawn’s past passion imprinted itself on her family’s structure, forcing everyone to renegotiate love’s terms in the open.
Character Connections
Dawn Edelstein: Dawn embodies the novel’s central bind—two sincere, incompatible loves demanding incompatible lives. Her struggle isn’t indecision but integrity: can she honor her roles as wife and mother without betraying the scholar and soulmate-seeker at her core, or is authenticity itself the fidelity she owes?
Brian Edelstein: Brian represents the durable, daily devotion of marriage—measured in presence, repair, and shared history. His near-infidelity underscores how even a steadfast partner can misplace attention, yet his capacity for forgiveness and continued commitment reframes love as an ongoing practice rather than a static state.
Wyatt Armstrong: Wyatt personifies the path not taken, a love that is as intellectual as it is physical. His steadfastness across years challenges the idea that time dissolves true connection, raising the question of whether some bonds are less chosen than recognized—and whether honoring them is obligation or temptation.
Winifred “Win” Morse: Win’s end-of-life reckoning serves as a moral mirror. By validating the persistence of first love within a good marriage, she dissolves easy judgments about fidelity and insists that living truthfully—even late—may be the most faithful act of all.
Symbolic Elements
The Book of Two Ways: The ancient map of the afterlife—one route by land, one by water—becomes Dawn’s existential atlas: Egypt/Wyatt versus Boston/Brian. The key isn’t which path is “right,” but that the routes do not converge; choosing one necessarily forsakes the other, and the soul must live with its map.
Roses: The perfume on Brian’s clothes crystallizes an invisible betrayal into a tangible sign. Each recurrence reactivates the moment trust faltered, making scent a trigger for memory and a measure of whether repair is possible.
Egypt and Boston: Settings double as states of being: Egypt is passion, vocation, and the self Dawn once was; Boston is stability, family, and the self she chose. Moving between them externalizes her interior divide, turning geography into an ethical and emotional crossroads.
Contemporary Relevance
In a world where old flames are a message away and emotional intimacy can migrate online, the novel’s view of fidelity feels acutely modern. It acknowledges that long-term partnerships evolve and that the fiercest temptations are often intellectual and emotional, not merely physical. The story also speaks to midlife audit culture—the urge to test past choices against present selves—and to how new technologies (like DNA testing) can surface truths that demand new forms of love, forgiveness, and boundary-setting.
Essential Quote
I have heard that when you are about to die, your life flashes before your eyes.
But I do not picture my husband, Brian... Or Meret, as a little girl...
Instead, I see him.
As clearly as if it were yesterday, I imagine Wyatt in the middle of the Egyptian desert... A man who hasn’t been part of my life for fifteen years.
This passage plants the theme in the body’s most honest reflex: whom the heart summons when it believes the end is near. By privileging Wyatt over her family, Dawn reveals that her marriage coexists with an undischarged love, casting the entire narrative as a reckoning with what fidelity demands—and what it costs—when desire, memory, and duty collide.