The Past's Influence on the Present
What This Theme Explores
This theme asks how earlier choices, loves, and losses remain active agents in the present rather than fading into memory. The novel treats the past as a parallel track that runs alongside the current moment—ready to intersect, reroute, or destabilize a life at any time. It explores how personal history and ancient history exert equal gravitational pull: private regrets and old romances shape identities just as Egypt’s artifacts and texts shape vocations and desires. In doing so, the book twines this theme with Choices and Alternate Paths and Regret and Unfinished Business, suggesting that reckoning with the past is the only way to live honestly in the present.
How It Develops
From the start, the structure—alternating “Water/Boston” and “Land/Egypt”—lets the past and present unspool side by side. In the Prologue, a near-death moment makes memory decisive: Dawn Edelstein does not picture her family but Wyatt Armstrong, and that involuntary recollection becomes action when she boards a plane to Egypt. The past isn’t merely remembered; it commandeers the plot.
In the middle of the novel, the dual timelines deepen the theme’s reach. The Boston chapters trace how Dawn’s marriage to Brian Edelstein was built in the vacuum left by Egypt and Wyatt, while the Egypt chapters collapse temporal distance altogether: Dawn works with Wyatt on a mystery seeded by their long-ago inscription. The past becomes her present occupation, forcing her to inhabit the life she once abandoned.
By the end, the revelation of Meret Edelstein’s parentage removes any illusion that the past is hypothetical. It doesn’t haunt from a distance; it lives in the body, reorganizing loyalties and truths in the here and now. The novel’s resolution is not a binary choice between two lives but an integration of what was with what is, reframing the future through unflinching honesty. For a holistic arc of these convergences, see the Full Book Summary.
Key Examples
Before the examples, note how each moment turns memory into momentum—moments from years ago that still dictate who acts, how, and why.
-
Dawn’s vision during the plane crisis: In extremis, her mind defaults to Wyatt rather than her husband or child, revealing the primacy of earlier love over current routine. The thought propels her to Egypt, where reflection becomes confrontation—a clean illustration of the past converting to present-tense choice.
-
The dipinto (rock inscription): A single ancient line discovered years earlier drives Wyatt’s entire career and reunites him with Dawn. The past here is both literal (ink on rock) and catalytic (a professional and emotional quest), showing how an old clue can script decades.
-
Brian’s grandmother’s story: Brian’s moral compass is formed by the legacy of a Holocaust survivor who protected another child and later found her again. That inheritance shapes Brian’s steadiness and compassion in the present—and is the narrative bridge that first draws Dawn toward him in hospice work.
-
Meret’s DNA test: Science affirms what memory and secrecy could not: the past is written into the present at the cellular level. The revelation dismantles the family’s existing narrative and forces all three adults to rebuild identities around the truth rather than the story they preferred.
Character Connections
Dawn is the theme’s core embodiment: her professional calling (helping others reconcile life endings) mirrors her private task of reconciling life beginnings—her early ambition, her scholarship, and her love for Wyatt. She learns that integrity requires not choosing one timeline and erasing the other, but stitching them into a single, livable fabric.
Wyatt lives in a present continuously animated by what was: his work, grief, and ambition all flow from formative losses and a shared discovery with Dawn. His fixation on the dipinto is less stubbornness than a philosophy—believing that what the past records is not inert but directive.
Brian represents a more recent past that still bruises the now: his near-infidelity opens fissures that the older past rushes through. Yet his steadiness, forged by family history, complicates easy judgments; he shows how a painful legacy can also cultivate ethical clarity and kindness.
Winifred 'Win' Morse operates as a compassionate mirror. As she faces death, her unresolved love and secret about her son surface with urgency. Win’s wish to send one last letter underscores that the need to set the record straight with the past intensifies, rather than fades, as life’s horizon nears.
Symbolic Elements
Archaeology and Egyptology: Excavation is the novel’s governing metaphor—digging, reading, and reassembling fragments to understand the present. The discipline insists that what’s buried still speaks, a creed the characters must adopt about their own histories.
The Book of Two Ways: This map of afterlife paths symbolizes the parallel tracks of Dawn’s life. Ancient guidance from the dead becomes a model for modern navigation: you only progress by honoring what came before.
Ghosts and memories: “Haunting” here is psychological rather than supernatural—memories that arrive with the force and presence of specters. The effect is to collapse temporal separation; the past becomes an active participant in current decisions.
Superstitions: The inherited beliefs from Dawn's Mother—ladders, omens, rituals—show how tradition quietly choreographs daily behavior. Even when irrational, these hand-me-downs prove the past’s subtle governance of the present.
Contemporary Relevance
In a world of algorithmic reminders and “On This Day” resurfacing, the past interrupts our feeds as surely as it interrupts Dawn’s life. DNA testing renders lineage undeniable, redrawing family trees and identities much like Meret’s revelation. And culturally, the tug of the “one that got away” or the road not taken echoes the novel’s insistence that we cannot self-invent without self-remembering. The book’s answer is not nostalgia or amnesia, but integration: owning the archive to author the next chapter.
Essential Quote
I have heard that when you are about to die, your life flashes before your eyes.
But I do not picture my husband, Brian... Or Meret...
Instead, I see him.
As clearly as if it were yesterday, I imagine Wyatt in the middle of the Egyptian desert... A man who hasn’t been part of my life for fifteen years. A place I left behind.
This moment crystallizes the theme: at the edge of death, the past asserts itself as the truest present. The involuntary memory exposes what has been running beneath Dawn’s daily life and immediately converts recollection into choice, sending her back to Egypt. The quote proves that the past is not a faded photograph but a live wire, capable of shocking the current moment into a new configuration.