Love and Infidelity
What This Theme Explores: The Perfect Marriage delves into the multifaceted theme of love and infidelity, dissecting how these forces drive the narrative far beyond simple marital unfaithfulness. It examines the decay of love, fueled by neglect, ambition, and simmering resentment, portraying infidelity as a symptom of deeper marital fractures rather than a standalone act. The novel questions whether love is a genuine emotion or a performance, and explores how it can be twisted to justify manipulation, betrayal, and violence. Ultimately, the story uses infidelity as a catalyst to shatter the illusion of perfection, exposing the transactional and often dark nature of relationships.
How It Develops
The theme of love and infidelity is introduced early on through the strained relationship between Sarah Morgan and Adam Morgan. Sarah's relentless career ambitions lead to emotional neglect, while Adam's bruised ego and resentment drive him into an affair with Kelly Summers. In these early stages, love is portrayed as conditional, taking a backseat to personal fulfillment, while infidelity emerges as an escape, a source of passion that is conspicuously absent from the Morgan marriage.
As the narrative progresses, Kelly's murder throws Adam's infidelity into sharp relief, making it the central motive in the prosecution's case. Sarah's love is tested as she defends her betraying husband, blurring the lines between wifely duty and professional obligation. The theme expands to include Kelly's own infidelity and her abusive marriage to Scott Summers, suggesting that infidelity is a cyclical pattern born from unhappiness and desperation.
The culmination of this theme arrives with the shocking revelation that Sarah's love was a carefully constructed façade. Her defense of Adam was not born from a desire to save her husband but from a calculated plan for revenge against his infidelity. Her new relationship with Bob Miller is a "perfect" love built on shared deception and murder, offering a dark commentary on the true nature of love.
Key Examples
Specific moments throughout the novel underscore the destructive and deceptive nature of love and infidelity.
-
Adam's Justification: Early in the book, Adam's perspective reveals his resentment toward Sarah's success and neglect. He feels emasculated and unloved, which he uses to rationalize his relationship with Kelly. Adam thinks,
After all, you don’t become the best criminal defense attorney by loving your husband. This quote from the Prologue Summary establishes the core conflict: Adam perceives Sarah's ambition as a direct rejection of her love for him, setting the stage for his infidelity.
-
Adam's Declaration of Love to Kelly: After sleeping with Kelly, Adam leaves a note that becomes a crucial piece of evidence, seemingly confessing his love for her and his desire to end his marriage.
Kelly, It’s you. It hasn’t always been you, but it will always be you. You’re the words to a story I’ve been trying to write my whole life, and tonight I determined the ending. This note, detailed in the Chapter 1-5 Summary, is interpreted by the prosecution as a motive for murder—the "ending" being Kelly's death. For Adam, it was a declaration of love that sealed his fate.
-
Sarah's Reaction to the Affair: When Sarah learns of Adam's infidelity, her reaction is not one of a heartbroken wife but of a calculating lawyer. She immediately separates her emotions from the case.
"Adam, I need you to understand, I am here as your lawyer, not your wife." This statement from the Chapter 11-15 Summary shows the complete erosion of their romantic connection. Love is replaced by a professional contract, though this itself is a deception.
-
The Final Revelation: The epilogue reveals that Sarah's entire defense of Adam was a performance. Her love had long since died, and her actions were motivated by a desire for revenge against his betrayal.
A divorce would have given Adam half of everything I own. He didn’t deserve that. He didn’t deserve me. I vowed to never be like my mother. Allowing any man to take what I had earned and what I had worked hard for would make me just as weak as she was. In the end, Adam got the one thing he did deserve. This chilling confession in the Chapter 61-64 Summary reframes the entire narrative. Sarah's actions were not about love or forgiveness, but about power, control, and a twisted form of justice for Adam's infidelity.
Character Connections
Adam Morgan embodies infidelity driven by emotional neglect and a wounded ego. He convinces himself he can love two women at once, revealing a selfish and compartmentalized view of love that ultimately leads to his downfall.
Sarah Morgan initially appears to be the victim of infidelity, a wife whose love is put to the ultimate test. However, she is the ultimate perpetrator of betrayal. Her love is a weapon, and her response to Adam's affair is not forgiveness but a meticulously planned revenge plot that demonstrates a complete absence of genuine affection.
As the "other woman," Kelly Summers is a catalyst for the plot. Her own infidelity appears to be a desperate escape from an abusive marriage, highlighting how lovelessness can breed betrayal. Her multiple affairs make her a complex victim whose own choices contribute to her tragic end.
Bob Miller's actions are fueled by a twisted love for his murdered brother. This love transforms into a vengeful partnership with Sarah, and their shared crime becomes the foundation for a new, deceptive romantic relationship.
Symbolism
The lake house, meant to be a sanctuary for Adam's writing and a romantic getaway for the couple, becomes the primary setting for his affair and Kelly's murder. It symbolizes the secret, rotten core of their "perfect" marriage, a place where the façade crumbles to reveal the truth.
Sarah's tenth-anniversary gift to Adam, the Patek Philippe watch, is a symbol of their marriage's façade. It is an expensive, beautiful object meant to represent a decade of love, but it is given at a time when their relationship is completely broken. It represents the material wealth that papers over their emotional bankruptcy.
The narrative contrasts two beds: the marital bed in D.C., where Sarah and Adam try to conceive a child in a desperate attempt to salvage their relationship, and the bed at the lake house, which is a stage for illicit passion and, ultimately, a brutal crime scene. The beds symbolize the stark difference between the public performance of love and the private reality of betrayal.
Contemporary Relevance
The theme of love and infidelity remains highly relevant in a contemporary context where social media often promotes an idealized version of relationships. The Morgans' "perfect marriage" mirrors the curated façades many people present to the world, hiding the private struggles and betrayals that occur behind closed doors. The novel taps into modern anxieties about work-life balance, emotional neglect in dual-career households, and the ease of leading a double life. The explosive consequences of Adam's affair serve as a timeless cautionary tale about the devastating impact of infidelity, resonating with readers who are fascinated by the dark side of seemingly perfect lives.
Essential Quote
A divorce would have given Adam half of everything I own. He didn’t deserve that. He didn’t deserve me. I vowed to never be like my mother. Allowing any man to take what I had earned and what I had worked hard for would make me just as weak as she was. In the end, Adam got the one thing he did deserve.
This quote encapsulates the novel's cynical view of love and the lengths to which one will go when scorned. Sarah's words reveal that her actions were not motivated by love or a desire to save her marriage, but by a cold, calculated desire for revenge and a determination to maintain her power and independence. It underscores the theme that love, when twisted by betrayal, can become a destructive force.