What This Theme Explores
Marital Breakdown and Betrayal in The Push probes how love erodes when partners inhabit different realities—and insist that only one is valid. It asks what happens when a marriage is built on idealized roles (the “good mother,” the “protector”) rather than a willingness to witness each other’s complexity. The theme expands betrayal beyond infidelity to include the quieter treasons of gaslighting, emotional abandonment, and the refusal to share the burden of grief. It ultimately confronts how generational trauma, postpartum distress, and parental expectations can corrode trust until the relationship becomes unrecognizable.
How It Develops
The marriage between Blythe Connor and Fox Connor begins as a rescue fantasy: his steadfast warmth promises to rewrite her painful past, and she seems to promise the domestic ideal he longs to secure. That myth takes root early—Fox’s faith that Blythe will be a flawless mother binds their love to a performance neither of them can sustain. When their daughter, Violet Connor, is born, the first fractures appear not as fights but as refusals to believe the same experience. Blythe’s anxiety, exhaustion, and intuitive alarm meet Fox’s certainty that everything is normal; love starts to curdle into skepticism.
As Violet’s behavior grows more unsettling, the marital split hardens into a “two-against-one” alignment. Fox interprets Blythe’s distress as incompetence rather than insight, and his protectiveness of Violet becomes a tacit indictment of his wife. Key incidents—the discovery of Blythe writing while Violet cries, the accumulation of small dismissals—convert doubt into doctrine: Blythe is the problem, Fox the defender, Violet the innocent. Physical intimacy fades with the trust, replaced by vigilant policing and strategic silences.
After Sam’s birth and death, the couple’s grief does not bind but bifurcates them. Blythe’s conviction that Violet is dangerous collides with Fox’s insistence on an accident, and their home becomes a courtroom where only one version of truth can win. The affair with Gemma does not ignite the breakdown; it ratifies it. By building a new family that appears to confirm his original ideal, Fox rewrites their history—casting Blythe out of the narrative of goodness he still craves—and the marriage dissolves with a devastating quiet.
Key Examples
-
The idealized beginning: Fox’s birthday list—“92. I love what a good mother you’ll be one day” (Chapter 1)—makes Blythe’s value contingent on a role he has already scripted. Love here becomes conditional prophecy, laying the groundwork for betrayal when reality refuses to match the forecast.
-
First emotional betrayal: When Blythe confides, “I think the baby hates me,” Fox tells her it’s “all in [her] head” and to “just relax more” (Chapter 11-15 Summary). The dismissal reframes her pain as pathology, converting a plea for partnership into evidence against her reliability.
-
The shattering of trust: Fox comes home to Blythe wearing headphones while Violet screams and demands, “What the fuck were you doing?” (Chapter 16-20 Summary). This moment becomes the origin story of his certainty: from here on, he sees a negligent mother and a child in need of rescue, not a woman drowning.
-
Final division in grief: After Sam’s death, Blythe suggests Violet pushed the stroller, and Fox refuses even to consider it—“Don’t do this. It was an accident” (Chapter 41-45 Summary). His choice of narrative doubles as a choice of allegiance, abandoning Blythe’s reality when she needs it held with her.
-
The ultimate betrayal articulated: Confronted about the affair, Fox says, “Sam isn’t why our marriage is falling apart. He doesn’t have anything to do with it” (Chapter 56-60 Summary). He disconnects their collapse from tragedy to reassign blame to Blythe herself, completing the moral exile that began with his earliest dismissals.
Character Connections
Blythe enters marriage seeking repair—a chance to build the tenderness her childhood with Cecilia refused her. Fox’s escalating disbelief weaponizes her deepest fear: that she is defective and unlovable. The breakdown ultimately pushes her toward a painful clarity: she must trust her perception even when it costs her the shelter of marriage.
Fox is the engine of betrayal not because he cheats, but because he cannot tolerate imperfection—his partner’s, his daughter’s, or his own. He needs family to mirror a wholesome self-image; when Blythe’s experience contradicts that picture, he chooses the picture. His gaslighting is less a plot than a worldview: loyalty to the ideal over loyalty to the person.
Violet is the catalyst that reveals the marriage’s fault lines. Whether by instinct or design, she behaves differently for each parent, which allows Fox to sustain his innocence narrative and isolates Blythe further. In the family’s triangle, Violet becomes the hinge that closes Blythe out.
Gemma functions as the proof-of-concept for Fox’s fantasy. With her, he can stage the serene domesticity he believes was stolen by Blythe’s “failure.” She is not merely a new partner but a replacement text—one that lets him pretend the story was always simple.
Symbolic Elements
The glowing house: Blythe watching Fox’s new home “glow at night like everything inside is on fire” turns domestic warmth into a mirage. Its light promises safety while burning with the knowledge that she has been exiled from that illusion.
The painting of mother and child: Purchased for Sam’s nursery to symbolize hope of repair, then damaged and punctured before being returned, the painting becomes a ledger of broken promises. What should signify tenderness instead records the violence done to Blythe’s vision of family.
The V necklace: A token of Fox’s devotion to Violet and the family ideal, the necklace becomes unwearable after the playground death. Removing it marks Blythe’s refusal to collude in a lie about who they are and what has happened.
Contemporary Relevance
The novel maps the subtle violences of modern relationships: how “support” can become surveillance, how social expectations of motherhood can turn honest struggle into evidence of failure. Its portrayal of gaslighting aligns with current conversations about psychological abuse and the way postpartum vulnerability can be dismissed as hysteria. In a culture that prizes curated family images, The Push warns that denying complexity doesn’t preserve love—it corrodes it. The antidote the book suggests is not perfection, but the hard discipline of believing one another when the truth is inconvenient.
Essential Quote
“Sam isn’t why our marriage is falling apart. He doesn’t have anything to do with it.” (Chapter 56-60 Summary)
This line crystallizes betrayal as a choice of narrative. By severing their breakup from shared tragedy, Fox rewrites the past to exonerate himself and condemn Blythe, enshrining the ideal over the intimate. It is the final refusal to inhabit her reality—a confession that his allegiance has always been to the family he imagined, not the one he had.