Deception and Hidden Truths
What This Theme Explores: Then She Was Gone delves into the pervasive nature of deception, exploring how lies, secrets, and buried truths shape individual lives and relationships. The novel examines the motivations behind deception, whether it stems from a desire to protect oneself, manipulate others, or cope with unbearable trauma. It questions the long-term consequences of living a lie and the potential for truth, however painful, to offer a path toward healing and resolution.
How It Develops
The theme of deception is introduced early with the initial false narrative surrounding Ellie Mack's disappearance. The police's theory that Ellie ran away becomes a convenient explanation, allowing some characters to avoid confronting a more sinister reality. This initial deception sets the stage for a series of escalating lies and hidden truths that gradually unravel as the story progresses.
As Laurel Mack begins to investigate Ellie's disappearance, she encounters new layers of deception. Her relationship with Floyd Dunn is built on a foundation of lies, as he conceals his true connection to Ellie and his role in the events surrounding her disappearance. Simultaneously, Laurel's daughter, Hanna Mack, hides her relationship with Theo Goodman, creating a secret life to avoid her mother's judgment.
The discovery of Ellie's remains further complicates the web of deception, as new false narratives emerge. The revelation of Noelle Donnelly's involvement and her faked pregnancy ultimately leads to the exposure of the most devastating truths: Noelle's kidnapping and imprisonment of Ellie, Floyd's murder of Noelle, and the true parentage of Poppy Dunn.
Key Examples
-
The Runaway Theory: The initial acceptance of the runaway theory by the police and Paul Mack represents a collective desire to avoid confronting a more disturbing reality. This deception allows them to maintain a semblance of normalcy and avoid the pain of acknowledging the possibility of foul play.
“It’s a sort of closure, I guess.”
There, right there—the nal nail in the dry box of bones of their marriage.
-
Noelle's Deceptive Lure: Noelle's act of luring Ellie to her house under the guise of offering a practice exam paper is a pivotal moment of deception. This seemingly innocent gesture masks her sinister intentions and sets in motion the tragic events that follow.
-
Hanna's Secret Relationship: Hanna's consistent lies to Laurel about her whereabouts, claiming to be at parties or with friends when she is actually with Theo, highlight the lengths to which she will go to protect her secret. The discovery of a florist's card signed "T" is a subtle clue to this hidden truth, which Hanna conceals out of fear of her mother's reaction.
-
Floyd's Calculated Introduction: Floyd's carefully orchestrated meeting with Laurel is a prime example of calculated deception. His research into her and Paul, including collecting newspaper clippings about Ellie's case, reveals his meticulous planning and manipulative nature.
-
The Faked Pregnancy: Noelle's elaborate lie about being pregnant with Floyd's child is a central deception that drives much of the plot. Sara-Jade's memory of seeing Noelle without a baby bump is a critical clue that unravels this deceit, exposing the depth of Noelle's obsession and manipulation.
“She was naked. And there was no bump. She was naked,” she repeats. “And there was no bump.”
-
The Stolen Candlesticks: The reappearance of Laurel's stolen art deco candlesticks in Poppy's bedroom (Chapter 46-50 Summary) serves as a tangible manifestation of hidden truths. These objects connect the past crime (the "burglary" Laurel attributed to Ellie) directly to Floyd and Noelle, solidifying their involvement and shattering Laurel's remaining illusions.
Character Connections
- Noelle Donnelly: As the primary antagonist, Noelle embodies the destructive power of deception. Her entire life is built on a foundation of lies, from faking pregnancies to kidnapping Ellie. These deceptions stem from a deep-seated desire to create the life and family she believes she deserves, regardless of the cost to others.
- Floyd Dunn: Floyd's character becomes increasingly entangled in deception as he attempts to protect Poppy and conceal Noelle's crimes. He hides her body, manipulates Laurel into a relationship, and conceals the truth about Poppy's parentage. His actions are motivated by a twisted sense of loyalty and a desire for redemption, blurring the lines between victim and perpetrator.
- Laurel Mack: Laurel is primarily a victim of deception, but she also engages in self-deception as a coping mechanism. For years, she clings to the hope of Ellie's return and ignores the dysfunction within her remaining family, particularly her strained relationship with Hanna. This self-deception allows her to avoid confronting the full extent of her grief and the disintegration of her family.
- Hanna Mack: Hanna's deception is rooted in self-preservation. She hides her relationship with Theo from Laurel to avoid painful judgment and comparisons to Ellie. This secret world allows her to experience happiness without her mother's interference, highlighting the complex dynamics of grief and family relationships.
Symbolism
- Noelle's House: The unassuming terraced house on Harlow Road is a potent symbol of hidden evil. Its ordinary exterior conceals the horrific truth of Ellie's fate, representing the idea that monsters can hide in plain sight, blending seamlessly into everyday life.
- The Basement: The pine-clad basement serves as both a literal and metaphorical prison. It is where Ellie is physically hidden from the world and where Noelle's darkest secrets are kept. It symbolizes the buried truths and repressed traumas that lie beneath the surface of the characters' lives, waiting to be unearthed.
- Poppy Dunn: Poppy is the living embodiment of a hidden truth. Her striking resemblance to Ellie is a constant, unsettling clue that things are not as they seem. She is the secret, hidden in plain sight, and her existence ultimately forces the truth to the surface, disrupting the carefully constructed lies that have sustained the characters for years.
- The Candlesticks: The stolen silver candlesticks serve as a tangible link between past and present deceptions. Their reappearance in Poppy's room is the key that unlocks Laurel's suspicion, physically connecting the lie of the "burglary" to the truth of Floyd and Noelle's involvement.
Contemporary Relevance
The theme of deception and hidden truths resonates deeply in a contemporary world saturated with curated social media identities and concerns about "fake news." The novel taps into a modern anxiety about the difficulty of discerning authenticity and the fear that the people we let into our lives may not be who they appear to be. Floyd's ability to construct a convincing, likable persona while hiding a monstrous secret mirrors the deceptive nature of online profiles and the ease with which people can manipulate perceptions. The story serves as a cautionary tale about trusting blindly and reminds readers that the most dangerous truths are often the ones hidden just beneath a placid, ordinary surface.
Essential Quote
“It was like a nightmare you couldn’t wake up from, the kind of nightmare where you were running but you weren’t getting anywhere.”
This quote encapsulates the suffocating nature of deception and the feeling of being trapped in a web of lies. The characters are constantly running from the truth, but their efforts are futile, as the secrets they try to bury continue to haunt them. The nightmare imagery underscores the psychological toll of living a lie and the desperate desire for escape.