At a Glance
Genre: Supernatural thriller/psychological thriller with police procedural elements Setting: Contemporary Utah and Idaho (Oquirrh Mountains, Kuna, Cascade) Perspective: Rotating first-person voices of three murdered women whose afterlives intersect
Opening Hook
Three women are murdered by the same man—but death doesn’t silence them. Bound to their killer, they discover they can nudge the living world, even as grief and fury threaten to consume them. What begins as horror turns into a fierce alliance as the victims find one another and refuse to fade. Their hunt for truth will save the next targets—if they can make someone listen.
Plot Overview
Ask For Andrea unfolds across staggered timelines and converging investigations, told by three women who witness their own murders and what follows. A Full Book Summary traces how vengeance, memory, and solidarity fuse into a battle for justice from beyond the veil.
Two years before the main events, Brecia Collier is killed and awakens as a spirit tethered to her murderer, James Carson. Roiling emotion becomes power: Brecia learns she can flicker lights and jolt electronics, a fragile lifeline to the world she’s lost. She follows James as he settles into suburbia with his wife, April Carson, and their daughters, Emma and Kimmie Carson, helpless as he plays the role of loving father while scouting his next victim.
A year later, James lures Meghan via the MatchStrike app and disposes of her body in Utah’s Oquirrh Mountains. Her spirit drifts alone for months—unseen, unheard—while her remains lie undiscovered, a haunting span captured in the Chapter 1-5 Summary. Meghan’s isolation hardens into resolve as she waits for someone to find her.
The catalyst is Skye, an 18-year-old barista in Kuna, Idaho, whose disappearance finally triggers a police search. Newly dead and terrified, Skye’s ghost collides with Brecia’s, and recognition detonates: same man, same method, same lie. Skye’s shock and Brecia’s rage fuse into purpose as they realize James is already grooming again—inside his own home.
As Skye’s case heats up, hikers discover Meghan’s remains in Utah, and Detective Domanska takes the lead. Two investigations begin to braid. Back in Kuna, Skye’s manager, Ken, flags the “hot chocolate guy” who lingered at the coffee shop. The detail points straight to James.
The ghosts—now a trio after Meghan finds them—teach themselves to communicate and coordinate, amplifying their limited influence on alarms, dreams, and screens. When James senses the police closing in, he bolts with his family to a remote cabin near Cascade, Idaho. The women realize, with dawning horror, that he intends to kill April and the girls to erase every loose end. In a frantic bid to reach the living, they flood April’s sleep with nightmares vivid enough to feel like warnings, pushing her toward escape.
The final sprint is breathless. April and her daughters flee through the woods and find help. Detectives search the Carsons’ home and uncover a crucial piece of evidence: Skye’s signature smiley-face coffee cup, tying James to her murder and, with Meghan’s case, sealing his fate. With justice achieved, the three narrators—bound by trauma but liberated by truth—can finally move on, their unfinished business resolved.
Central Characters
For a full roster and deeper profiles, see the Character Overview.
The Protagonists
- Brecia Collier: The first victim and the book’s initial anchor. Fueled by incandescent rage, Brecia discovers her ability to manipulate electronics and becomes the trio’s strategist—relentless, focused, and unwilling to let James vanish into respectability.
- Meghan: Initially lost in the wilderness of death, she evolves from isolation to purpose once her remains are found and she connects with the others. Meghan brings quiet steadiness and empathy, tempering rage into method.
- Skye: The youngest and most recent victim, whose disappearance catalyzes the investigation. Skye’s perspective injects urgency and heartbreak; her presence re-energizes the pursuit and keeps the cost of delay painfully clear.
The Antagonist
- James Carson: A polished, churchgoing family man who weaponizes charm to hunt women online. His outward decency hides a predator’s meticulous ritual. The novel uses his facade to examine how evil thrives behind ordinary masks.
Supporting Characters
- April Carson: Wife, mother, and reluctant witness to the cracks in her reality. Her arc moves from denial to terror to action, culminating in a courageous break from the narrative James wrote for her.
- Detective Domanska: The living world’s instrument of justice—patient, intuitive, and willing to trust her instincts as disparate clues converge.
- Ken: Skye’s manager, whose “hot chocolate guy” tip helps link the coffee shop to James, bridging everyday detail and forensic proof.
- Emma and Kimmie Carson: Innocent observers within the killer’s home, their safety becomes the ghosts’ most urgent priority and exposes the stakes of James’s double life.
Major Themes
The novel’s alternating voices braid grief, cunning, and solidarity into a single arc. For deeper analysis, see the Theme Overview.
-
Vengeance and Post-Mortem Justice: Death does not end the fight; it relocates it. Brecia, Meghan, and Skye convert rage and sorrow into agency, nudging technology, planting dreams, and steering investigators until the truth surfaces. Justice here is not a courtroom ideal but a hard-won act of will from the margins of reality.
-
Predation and Violence Against Women: The novel confronts the risks women shoulder in spaces that promise connection—especially online dating. James’s pleasant persona is the bait, the system’s blind spots the trap. The title nods to the “Ask for Andrea” code, a safety net the victims couldn’t reach in time, sharpening the book’s real-world resonance.
-
Afterlife and Sisterhood: What might have been a solitary haunting becomes a community. In death, the women gain what isolation denied them in life: solidarity, shared purpose, and the courage to keep going. Their bond turns haunting into resistance.
-
Deception and Duality: James’s public virtue and private brutality expose how easily cruelty hides in plain sight. The story also tracks April’s shift from self-protective ignorance to clarity, demonstrating how denial enables predators—and how seeing clearly can save lives.
Literary Significance
Ask For Andrea stands out for fusing ghost story, thriller, and procedural while centering victims’ voices. By making the murdered women the narrators, Noelle W. Ihli recenters the genre’s gaze: the emotional core is grief and grit, not voyeuristic fascination with a killer. The result is suspense driven by urgency and empathy as readers watch the living inch toward answers the dead already know.
“I wasn’t breathing hard because I wasn’t breathing at all.”
That line captures the book’s tonal precision—intimate, visceral, and grounded in the strange realism of being present but unheard.
Historical Context
- The digital dating landscape: The MatchStrike stand-in evokes platforms where curated personas can mask predation, reflecting contemporary anxieties about meeting strangers online.
- The “Ask for Angela” initiative: Renamed “Andrea” in the novel, the real campaign allows patrons to discreetly seek help in bars, anchoring the story’s stakes in practical, existing safety measures.
- True crime’s boom: Released amid a surge of podcasts and documentaries, the book leverages popular interest while refusing to sideline victims, reframing the narrative center of gravity.
Critical Reception
Readers and critics praise the novel’s originality and pace, especially its decision to let the victims speak. The evolving “sisterhood” of ghosts is widely cited as the book’s beating heart, lending catharsis to a tense procedural spine. Some prefer greater realism or a more psychologically intricate portrait of James, whose function remains deliberately monstrous rather than nuanced.
Overall, Ask For Andrea is a sharp, affecting reinvention of the thriller—propulsive, empathetic, and thematically urgent. For memorable lines that showcase its voice, see selected Quotes.