Opening
A media firestorm after the “Aging Unevenly” exposé pushes Avery Stafford to dig harder into her family’s past—until she uncovers a secret that rewrites their legacy. Her search collides with the buried life of Judy Stafford (Fern Foss), and with the childhood of a girl once called Rill, whose last act of love costs her everything.
What Happens
Chapter 21: Avery
The Staffords stagger under hostile headlines suggesting they buy better care for Grandma Judy, and Avery watches her father, mid-chemotherapy, shoulder the scrutiny. Elliot arrives unannounced, eager to soothe and steer. In the gazebo, Avery confides her investigation into May Crandall and the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. Elliot’s response lands like a slap—he calls it “ancient history,” criticizes Judy as “too outspoken for her own good,” and aligns with Bitsy’s view that Judy nearly derailed the men’s political careers. The condescension exposes a values rift. They table the argument and make polite stabs at wedding talk, reaching nothing.
At Magnolia Manor, Judy has a lucid spark. She begs Avery to burn the contents of a closet at her old Lagniappe house—her daybooks and the “Miss Chief” society columns—then slips into confusion, mistaking Avery for “Beth.” Gutted, Avery leaves, only to be drawn into a new mystery: a taxi idling at Judy’s empty house. The young driver, Oz, explains he’s been prepaid to take Judy every Thursday to a spot near Augusta—years in the making. Avery rides along and calls Trent Turner to follow. Down an overgrown drive by the Savannah River, they find the ruins of a plantation house and, tucked beyond it, a hidden cottage.
Chapter 22: Rill
In 1940, Rill Foss (May Crandall) and Fern live uneasily with the Seviers when Georgia Tann arrives to squeeze them. Rill overhears Tann blackmailing Mrs. Sevier—fabricating a custody petition by the girls’ grandmother and demanding thousands in “legal fees” to make the trouble vanish—an emblem of Corruption of Power and Exploitation of the Vulnerable. Mr. Sevier rages; Mrs. Sevier, terrified, suggests they flee to her family home, Bellegrove, in Augusta. Rill sees the danger and decides: she and Fern must run now.
She enlists Arney McCamey, a builder’s “boy” who trusts Rill enough to reveal she’s actually Arnelle, working in disguise. Rill promises Mrs. Sevier’s pearl necklace if Arney will guide them through the slough in her father’s jon boat. Under a full moon, Rill carries sleeping Fern to the water. They thread the dark channels, reach the Mississippi, and cling to hope when they spot the shantyboat—Arcadia—at Mud Island. Silas rushes to meet them with news that tears the world: their mother, Queenie Foss, died three weeks earlier of blood poisoning—“a broke heart,” Zede says—and their father, Briny Foss, has drowned himself in grief and whiskey.
Chapter 23: Avery
Avery and Trent comb the river cottage and confirm it belongs to May Crandall. On the walls: photographs, fragments of a shared life, and a luminous painting, italic-titled SISTERS’ DAY, showing four women on a beach—Grandma Judy, May, and two others—signed “Fern.” Their search is cut short by a caretaker, Bart, and his dog. Hearing Avery’s name, Bart brings them to his mother, Hootsie—the same Hootsie from Rill’s river past.
Hootsie recognizes the Stafford name and retrieves a dented tin crucifix that belonged to Queenie and three yellowed pages of a letter by Judy—the book’s Prelude. The letter reveals Judy was born a twin in Baltimore on August 3, 1939, declared stillborn or taken in the delivery room, and then quietly adopted by the Staffords through Georgia Tann. Truth locks into place: Judy Stafford is Fern Foss. The cottage has been a sanctuary where the surviving sisters—May (Rill), Judy (Fern), and Lark—meet in secret. “Bring her,” Hootsie urges. “The heart still know. It still know who it loves.”
Chapter 24: Rill
Back on the ruined Arcadia, Briny drinks and drifts while Silas and Old Zede keep the girls fed. Zede lays down an ultimatum: in four days he heads downriver, with or without Briny; if Briny won’t go, he’ll take the girls himself. A violent storm breaks. In a fit of madness, Briny cuts Arcadia free. The river hurls them against a drift pile; a tugboat’s wake pitches the shantyhouse, the woodstove overturns, and flames race the timbers. Rill fights through smoke, finds Fern under a bunk, and drags her out, snatching the photo of their parents and Queenie’s tin cross as they scramble onto the burning debris.
Men in a lifeboat haul them aboard as Arcadia burns and sinks. From the bank, Rill glimpses Briny turn away and vanish into the trees. Silas finds the girls, but Rill has already made her brutal choice. The river life is over. Zede can’t raise them. To save Fern, Rill will surrender herself: she asks Silas to take them back upriver to the Seviers. As they leave the Mississippi, she lets the name Rill Foss go under. She becomes May Weathers.
Chapter 25: Avery
Avery sits with May in the nursing home, absorbing the whole story. May describes how the Seviers opened their home again and became a true family. The sisters kept their bond hidden to protect the lives they built. Armed with truth, Avery orchestrates a reunion at the river cottage, which Trent, Hootsie, and Bart prepare. She brings May and invites her parents and Grandma Judy.
Judy steps into the cottage and, despite dementia, knows her sister in a breath. They slip into “Sisters’ Day” talk like they’ve never been apart. On the porch, Avery tells her parents everything. Her father is stunned into silence; her mother trembles at the political fallout. Avery asks for one thing only: let the sisters have their time. Later, walking the plantation ruins with Trent, Avery says she’s ended her engagement to Elliot; the match was expectation, not love. Trent asks to hold her hand. She says yes, and together they turn from the ruins toward an undefined, honest future.
Character Development
Across these chapters, private loyalties clash with public lives. Choices—not circumstances—define who these people become.
-
Avery Stafford: From dutiful political heiress to independent truth-teller. She refuses to minimize the past, prioritizes people over optics, and ends an engagement that no longer fits.
- Defies Elliot’s insistence on silence about May and the Home Society.
- Tracks Judy’s secret Thursdays and follows the trail to the river cottage.
- Breaks the engagement and chooses a life guided by conviction.
-
Rill Foss (May Crandall): Courage calcifies into sacrifice. She trades her name for Fern’s safety and refashions herself as May—an identity built on love and loss.
- Engineers a nighttime river escape to reclaim family.
- Saves Fern from the burning Arcadia.
- Returns Fern to the Seviers and lets “Rill” die so “May” can live.
-
Judy Stafford (Fern Foss): Identity revealed, essence intact. Dementia clouds facts but not love; she still recognizes her sister, and her secret “Miss Chief” archives point to a lifetime of coded self-expression.
- Keeps weekly pilgrimages to the cottage for years.
- Writes the letter that bridges timelines and reveals her origin.
-
Briny Foss: A loving father undone by grief. His final act—cutting the Arcadia loose and disappearing—shatters the last illusions about the river “kingdom.”
- Succumbs to alcoholism after Queenie’s death.
- Abandons the girls at the river’s edge.
-
Elliot: The polished embodiment of status and control. His dismissiveness (“ancient history”) and alignment with Bitsy mark him as misaligned with Avery’s values.
-
Trent: Steady, curious, kind. He investigates without judgment, follows Avery’s lead, and offers emotional safety as she reclaims her path.
-
Core theme tie-in: Rill’s sacrifice embodies The Enduring Power of Family Bonds, showing how love survives even when identity must be shed.
Themes & Symbols
-
The Search for Identity and Truth: The Search for Identity and Truth crests here. Avery exposes the secret at the heart of the Stafford story, while Rill relinquishes her original name to protect Fern. The novel juxtaposes discovery and erasure: one woman finds her lineage; another buries hers to save her sister.
-
Secrets and Their Consequences: Secrets and Their Consequences ripple through generations. The sisters’ private reunions safeguard their families but cost them open belonging. Avery’s choice to reveal the truth invites scandal yet promises healthier legacies built on honesty rather than curated myth.
Symbols
- The River: Life-giver and destroyer. It raises the Foss children and then devours their home, turning heritage into hazard.
- The Arcadia: A floating Eden reduced to ash. Its destruction marks the end of a childhood kingdom and the death of “Rill.”
- The Cottage: Sanctuary and archive. It holds the sisters’ hidden gatherings, photographs, and the letter that binds timelines.
- The Tin Cross and Family Photo: Portable relics of identity that survive catastrophe—proof that memory can be carried when homes cannot.
- The Painting, SISTERS’ DAY: Art as witness. A visual vow that the sisters’ bond endures despite time, distance, and secrecy.
Key Quotes
“Ancient history.” / “Too outspoken for her own good.” These phrases from Elliot compress decades of abuse and theft into something dismissible and blame a victim for speaking. The language exposes his allegiance to image control over empathy, pushing Avery to reject the life he represents.
“The heart still know. It still know who it loves.” Hootsie’s assurance reframes memory beyond cognition. Even as dementia erodes Judy’s timeline, love recognizes its object—foreshadowing the instant recognition between sisters at the cottage.
“Rill Foss must die with her kingdom.” Rill’s resolution captures the psychological death-and-rebirth at the river’s edge. In sacrificing her name for Fern’s future, she claims agency within powerlessness—and defines May Weathers through choice, not fate.
“SISTERS’ DAY.” The painting’s title becomes a ritual and a thesis: sisterhood as ceremony, remembrance, and resistance to the erasures imposed by theft, adoption, and secrecy.
“Aging Unevenly.” The exposé’s headline crystallizes a world divided by privilege. It frames Avery’s journey from complacency to confrontation with the costs of her family’s curated reputation.
Why This Matters and Section Significance
These chapters deliver the novel’s emotional and narrative convergence. Avery’s investigation meets Rill’s buried past; the photograph, the letter, and the cottage weave both timelines into a single truth: Judy Stafford is Fern Foss. Mysteries resolve—the woman in the photo, Judy’s Thursday taxi rides, the fate of the Foss children—while the symbolic destruction of the Arcadia seals the end of the river world and births May Weathers.
The fallout reshapes lives. Rill’s sacrifice defines her adulthood; Avery’s choice to break her engagement and center truth over optics redefines hers. The reunion grants catharsis without erasing harm, affirming that family bonds endure even when history is fractured—and that healing begins where secrecy ends.