This character guide explores the cast of Riley Sager's Home Before Dark, a novel that masterfully interweaves the present with the past. Through alternating narratives—Maggie Holt's present-day investigation and excerpts from her father's book, House of Horrors—the characters are presented in dual perspectives, blurring the lines between reality and fiction. This structure allows for a deeper exploration of their motivations, secrets, and the haunting legacy of Baneberry Hall.
Main Characters
Maggie Holt
As the protagonist of the present-day narrative, Maggie Holt is a pragmatic home renovator who inherits Baneberry Hall twenty-five years after her family's infamous departure. Skeptical of the supernatural, she returns to the house to prepare it for sale, determined to debunk her father's sensationalized account of their time there. Haunted by fragmented memories and the notoriety of her family's past, Maggie embarks on a quest to uncover the truth behind House of Horrors, questioning everyone involved and challenging the narrative that has defined her life. Her journey is one of confronting repressed trauma and piecing together the dark history of her family and Baneberry Hall itself.
Maggie's relationship with her deceased father, Ewan Holt, is complex, marked by love, frustration, and a sense of betrayal over his lifelong deception. Her relationship with her mother, Jess Holt, is strained by Jess's refusal to discuss the past, a silence Maggie desperately seeks to break. The arrival of Dane Hibbets, the caretaker of Baneberry Hall, further complicates matters, as their connection is intertwined with the house's secrets and the central mystery surrounding the disappearance of Petra Ditmer.
Ewan Holt
Ewan Holt is the narrator of House of Horrors and Maggie's recently deceased father, whose "true story" of the haunting at Baneberry Hall catapulted his family to fame. Ewan's character is explored through his writing and Maggie's memories, revealing a man deeply conflicted by the choices he made. A gifted storyteller, Ewan crafted a compelling narrative that blurred the lines between fact and fiction, creating a global phenomenon that haunted his family for decades. Despite the fame and fortune it brought, Ewan carried a heavy burden of guilt, driven by a desire to protect Maggie from a devastating truth.
Ewan's relationship with Maggie is defined by his fierce love and the lengths he went to shield her from the consequences of her own actions. His marriage to Jess was ultimately destroyed by the strain of maintaining the lie, leading to their divorce. Ewan's posthumous arc reveals a man grappling with an impossible moral dilemma, leaving behind a written confession for Maggie that finally unveils the true story and his profound regret.
Jess Holt
Jess Holt is Maggie's mother and Ewan's ex-wife, who was present during the twenty days at Baneberry Hall and complicit in the cover-up that followed. In the present, she is reluctant to revisit the past, creating tension with Maggie. For twenty-five years, Jess has adhered to the pact she made with Ewan, refusing to discuss the events at Baneberry Hall. While she initially agreed to Ewan's plan, the constant deception and guilt wore her down, ultimately leading to the dissolution of her marriage.
Like Ewan, Jess's primary motivation is protecting Maggie, even if it means sacrificing her own happiness and well-being. Her relationship with Maggie is defined by the secret that stands between them, a source of deep frustration for Maggie. However, the discovery of Petra's body forces Jess to confront the truth, culminating in an act of ultimate sacrifice as she attempts to take the blame for Petra's death to protect Maggie, finally revealing the depth of her love and guilt.
Supporting Characters
Marta Carver
Initially presented as the tragic previous owner of Baneberry Hall, whose husband Curtis Carver murdered their daughter before killing himself, Marta Carver is revealed to be the primary antagonist. She masterfully cultivates an image of a grieving widow, hiding her true, sinister nature and harboring a dangerous obsession with Maggie, whom she views as a surrogate for her lost daughter. Marta's deceptive nature and ruthlessness make her a chilling villain, responsible for Petra Ditmer's death and the attempted murder of Maggie.
Petra Ditmer
The sixteen-year-old babysitter whose disappearance is the central mystery of the novel, Petra Ditmer vanished the same night the Holts fled Baneberry Hall. Described as vivacious and flirtatious, she was secretly dating Dane Hibbets against her mother's wishes. Petra's concern for Maggie's safety led to her fatal confrontation with Marta Carver, making her a tragic victim whose murder was covered up for twenty-five years.
Dane Hibbets
The current caretaker of Baneberry Hall and grandson of the original caretaker, Walt Hibbets, Dane Hibbets serves as a guide for Maggie, a potential love interest, and a major red herring in the murder of Petra Ditmer. His charming demeanor and capable nature quickly build a rapport with Maggie, but his secret relationship with Petra and his criminal past make him a prime suspect. Despite ultimately being proven innocent of Petra's murder, his connection to the tragedy and his dishonesty about it permanently fractures his relationship with Maggie.
Curtis Carver
Marta's husband and the man believed to have murdered his daughter, Katie, at Baneberry Hall, Curtis Carver is portrayed in House of Horrors as a victim of the house's malevolent spirits. His suicide note reveals he was suffering from severe depression, exacerbated by his daughter's mysterious illness. Curtis is a tragic figure whose story is manipulated by others, his true suffering largely ignored as he is vilified by the town and used as a fictional device by Ewan.
Indigo Garson
The "original ghost" of Baneberry Hall in Ewan's book, Indigo Garson is said to have killed herself with baneberries after her father forbade her from eloping. Her story provides the foundational myth for the haunting in House of Horrors, recasting her as a vengeful spirit who makes fathers harm their daughters. While her death was real, her role as a vengeful ghost is pure fiction, a narrative device Ewan uses to explain the inexplicable events and build his supernatural tale.
Minor Characters
-
Elsa Ditmer: Petra and Hannah Ditmer's mother and the housekeeper for Baneberry Hall. A deeply religious and superstitious woman, her fragmented memories and warnings are crucial to the story.
-
Hannah Ditmer: Petra's younger sister. As an adult, she is bitter and cynical, convinced Ewan Holt was responsible for her sister's disappearance.
-
Walt "Hibbs" Hibbets: The original caretaker and Dane's grandfather. In House of Horrors, he serves as a classic horror trope: the old-timer who warns the new family about the property's dark past.
-
Chief Tess Alcott: The police officer who first took the Holts' statement and is the chief of police in the present day.
-
William Garson: The wealthy lumber man who built Baneberry Hall in 1875. In Ewan's book, he is the patriarchal villain whose cruelty led to his daughter Indigo's death, thereby cursing the house.
Character Relationships
The relationships in Home Before Dark are a complex web of family ties, secrets, and lies, spanning twenty-five years and connecting the Holt, Carver, and Ditmer families.
-
The Holt Family: Ewan and Jess's marriage is destroyed by the secret they keep to protect their daughter, Maggie, whose entire life is shaped by the lie her parents told. Her quest for truth forces them to confront the past.
-
The Carver Family: Curtis and Marta's story is the public tragedy that sets the stage for the Holts' arrival. The truth of their relationship is far different from the murder-suicide narrative. Their daughter, Katie, is a victim of a mysterious illness, her death wrongly attributed to her father.
-
The Ditmer Family: Elsa's fragmented memories and warnings are crucial to the story. Her daughter Petra's disappearance connects all the families, while her other daughter, Hannah's grief and suspicion drive her actions in the present.
-
Baneberry Hall Staff: Walt Hibbets, the original caretaker, and his grandson Dane, the current caretaker, are both connected to the house's dark past. Dane's secret relationship with Petra makes him a key figure in the mystery.
Character Themes
-
The Protector (Ewan, Jess, Elsa): Several characters are driven by a fierce, often destructive, need to protect their children. Ewan and Jess construct an elaborate lie that ruins their marriage to save Maggie from the consequences of her actions. Elsa Ditmer, in her own way, tries to protect Maggie by acting as "Mister Shadow" and ultimately intervenes to save her from Marta. This theme explores the moral complexities of parental love, as seen in the theme of Family Secrets and Their Consequences.
-
The Victim (Petra, Curtis, Maggie): The novel is filled with characters who are victimized, not just by violence, but by the narratives forced upon them. Petra is murdered and her memory is tarnished. Curtis Carver is falsely remembered as a monster. Maggie is a victim of her parents' lie and the public persona created for her by the Book.
-
The Deceiver (Marta, Ewan, Hannah): Deception is a central character trait. Marta Carver's deception is the most sinister, as she hides her identity as a killer behind a mask of grief. Ewan's deception is born of desperation and love. Hannah's is smaller in scale, driven by financial need and resentment. These characters highlight the theme of Truth vs. Fiction and the Unreliability of Narrative.
-
The Skeptic vs. The Believer (Maggie vs. Ewan's Narrative): The central conflict is driven by Maggie's skepticism clashing with the "believer" narrative her father created. Maggie represents logic and reason, while the story of House of Horrors represents the supernatural and emotional. Her journey forces her to question the line between the two, embodying the theme of Supernatural vs. Psychological Horror.