At a Glance
- Genre: Literary crime thriller; coming-of-age mystery
- Setting: Minnesota (Twin Cities and rural Midwest), harsh winter backdrop; echoes of Vietnam
- Perspective: First-person (Joe), with documents and recollections enriching the timeline
- Publication: 2014; debut novel by Allen Eskens
Opening Hook
A college assignment shouldn’t end with a gun in your face and a blizzard closing in, but that’s where this one goes. What begins as a visit to a nursing home turns into a quest to clear a dying man’s name and solve a girl’s long-cold murder. To follow the truth, a student must reckon with his own broken family, a neighbor’s guarded past, and the secrets a respectable Midwestern household buried for three decades. In a world where perception becomes evidence, the hardest part is deciding whom to believe—and how much it will cost.
Plot Overview
Act I: Assignment, Upheaval, and a Dying Confession
At the University of Minnesota, Joe Talbert scrambles to complete an English biography project and escape the chaos of his home life. He’s the de facto guardian for his autistic brother, Jeremy Talbert, thanks to an alcoholic mother who detonates whatever stability remains. When she’s arrested for a DUI, Joe drags Jeremy into his cramped apartment, where their sharp-eyed neighbor, Lila Nash, surprises him with kindness toward Jeremy and skepticism toward the world. For the assignment, Joe interviews Carl Iverson, a Vietnam veteran and convicted murderer paroled to a nursing home with terminal cancer. In the first few chapters, Carl’s steely honesty—and his insistence he didn’t kill the fourteen-year-old victim—pulls Joe into a story he can’t shake.
Act II: Cracks in the Case
Joe secures Carl’s trial file and tracks down the veteran’s closest friend, Virgil Gray, who attests to Carl’s heroism and the scars he carried home from war. With Lila’s help, Joe pores over crime scene photos and the diary of the murdered girl, Crystal Hagen. The journal is written in code—until Jeremy, watching Lila type, idly mentions “The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog,” the key that unlocks the substitution cipher. The decoded entries reveal abuse and blackmail by someone Crystal calls “DJ,” pointing Joe toward her stepfamily. Suspicion falls on her stepfather, Douglas Lockwood, who reacts with sudden brutality: he knocks Joe unconscious, chains him to cinder blocks, and stuffs him into the trunk of his car. In a whiteout blizzard, Joe claws free and staggers to a remote hunting cabin, alive but shaken—and convinced the past is not what it seems.
Act III: The Blizzard Breaks—and the Truth Emerges
Recovering, Joe and Lila realize their fatal error: “DJ” isn’t Douglas, but Crystal’s stepbrother, Dan "DJ" Lockwood. They chase a DNA lead to Iowa, but the plan backfires. Warned by his father, Dan abducts Lila and lures Joe to the deserted Lockwood farm, turning the investigation into a hostage standoff. Joe covertly alerts Detective Max Rupert before walking into the barn where Dan intends to execute them both. The rescue is seconds from too late: Rupert arrives and shoots Dan, ending a spree that posthumously links him to Crystal’s murder and other killings.
In the aftermath, the truth clears the innocent and reshapes the living. Carl’s name is officially exonerated just hours before he dies, finally unburdened. Joe and Lila receive a reward for solving the cold cases; more importantly, Joe secures legal guardianship of Jeremy and a path to stay in school. The case that began as homework becomes the hinge on which all their futures turn.
Central Characters
Complex, wounded, and resilient, these characters drive both the mystery and the emotional core.
-
Joe Talbert: A guarded college student running from a dysfunctional upbringing, Joe learns that courage is less about bravado than about showing up for family. The investigation forces him to face guilt over his grandfather’s death, accept responsibility for Jeremy, and trust love when it finds him in Lila.
-
Carl Iverson: Introduced as a paroled “monster,” Carl emerges as a man shaped by moral injury—someone who can live with pain but not with lies. His mentorship pushes Joe toward integrity; his dying wish isn’t just absolution, but a chance to prove that a life can be more than its worst chapter.
-
Lila Nash: Wary and incisive, Lila hides vulnerability behind sarcasm. Her own trauma initially hardens her against Carl, yet her intellect and sense of justice tie her to Joe’s quest. Through partnership and peril, she relearns trust, balancing independence with connection.
-
Jeremy Talbert: Jeremy’s literal thinking and routine-bound calm become unexpected strengths—his casual remark solves the diary’s cipher. Beyond plot mechanics, he anchors Joe to a vision of family that is chosen, tender, and fiercely protected.
-
Virgil Gray: Loyal to Carl and unsentimental about war, Virgil provides both testimony and moral ballast. His stories blur heroism and harm, underscoring how survival can look like guilt from the outside.
-
Douglas Lockwood: The respectable patriarch whose violence betrays a family built on secrets. His actions expose the rot beneath suburban normalcy and misdirect the investigation, nearly to a lethal end.
-
Dan “DJ” Lockwood: The true predator. Charismatic menace and calculated cruelty mark him as a serial killer whose crimes depended on silence—and on a community’s willingness to see what it wanted to see.
Major Themes
For deeper exploration, see the full Theme Overview.
-
Truth, Lies, and Perception: The official version of Crystal’s murder is tidy—and wrong. The novel shows how narratives harden into facts when institutions prefer closure over accuracy, and how chasing truth requires skepticism, patience, and moral risk.
-
Guilt and Atonement: Joe’s childhood guilt and Carl’s wartime remorse mirror each other, suggesting that atonement demands action, not self-punishment. By seeking the real killer, both men move from private shame to reparative purpose.
-
Family Dysfunction and Responsibility: Two families, two outcomes. Joe’s fractured home compels him to grow into a protector for Jeremy, while the Lockwoods’ secrecy and abuse incubate violence; responsibility becomes the line between damage and destruction.
-
Justice and the Flaws of the Legal System: Carl’s wrongful conviction exposes a system that closes cases faster than it corrects errors. Real justice, Eskens argues, often arrives from outsiders willing to re-open what the courts consider settled.
-
Burdens of the Past: Every character carries a “life” they’ve buried—traumas, mistakes, and ghosts that dictate present choices. The novel insists that peace only comes when those histories are unearthed and owned.
Literary Significance
The Life We Bury distinguishes itself by marrying the propulsion of a legal thriller to the emotional clarities of a coming-of-age story. Its moral complexity—where a convicted killer becomes a mentor and the most “normal” family hides the darkest secret—invites readers to question surface judgments and institutional narratives. Eskens’s debut is meticulously plotted yet character-driven, using a Midwestern winter as both landscape and metaphor for isolation, clarity, and survival. Widely acclaimed and award-winning, the novel helped redefine modern crime fiction’s possibilities: a page-turner with a conscience, where solving a murder becomes a test of identity, loyalty, and grace.