Female Solidarity and Empowerment
What This Theme Explores
The novel examines how women build covert systems of care and resistance in a world designed to silence them. It asks what empowerment looks like when public power is denied, and whether quiet, collective action can be as radical as open revolt. It also probes the ethical edges of solidarity—when protection becomes vengeance, and who gets included or excluded from the circle of care. Across centuries, the story suggests that women’s shared knowledge, trust, and remembrance constitute a durable form of power.
How It Develops
The theme begins in secrecy and need. In 1791, Nella Clavinger has transformed her mother’s healing shop into a hidden refuge for women with no legal recourse against violent men. Her rule—only women enter—turns a backroom apothecary into a sanctuary where whispers, remedies, and resolve circulate away from the gaze of patriarchal authority. In the modern timeline, Caroline Parcewell sets out on what seems a private act of reclamation: she takes the planned anniversary trip to London alone after discovering her husband’s infidelity. What starts as self-preservation becomes a search for lineage—who she might be if she listens to the women who came before.
As the plot deepens, solidarity becomes intergenerational apprenticeship. The improbable bond between Nella and Eliza Fanning grows from errands into trust, and the apothecary register emerges as the physical ledger of a clandestine sisterhood—names, ailments, and acts of resistance written into history. Meanwhile, Caroline’s tentative connections in the present—especially her friendship with Gaynor—model a contemporary version of the same network: women sharing expertise, cheering risk, and safeguarding each other’s choices.
By the end, solidarity demands sacrifice. Eliza’s leap from Blackfriars Bridge saves Nella and protects the register’s women, converting private loyalty into public consequence. The historical story’s hard-won resilience reverberates forward: Caroline, moved by the record of women who refused erasure, chooses a life aligned with her intellect and desire, leaving her marriage and reclaiming her academic path (Chapter 36). The past doesn’t just inform the present; it authorizes it.
Key Examples
Moments across both timelines reveal how women create power through connection, remembrance, and risk.
-
Nella’s founding principle Nella’s insistence that “only girls come here” evolves her mother’s practice into a covert safety net. The shop’s gendered boundary is protective, not exclusionary: it asserts that women’s needs—and their secrets—deserve a guarded space.
My mother had held tight to this principle, instilling in me from an early age the importance of providing a safe haven—a place of healing—for women. London grants little to women in need of tender care; instead, it crawls with gentlemen’s doctors, each as unprincipled and corrupt as the next. (Chapter 3)
-
The register as collective memory The calfskin register records not crimes but claims: a written insistence that these women existed and acted. By preserving names that official histories would ignore, Nella converts secrecy into legacy and makes remembrance itself an act of empowerment.
"For many of these women," Nella whispered, "this may be the only place their names are recorded. The only place they will be remembered... The world is not kind to us... There are few places for a woman to leave an indelible mark." (Chapter 15)
-
Caroline’s solo mudlarking Caroline’s decision to venture out alone marks a pivot from containment to curiosity. Defying a partner who once set her limits, she tests her own appetite for risk and discovery—first in the mud, then in her life.
No doubt James would have resisted this spontaneous adventure, but he wasn’t here to hold me back. Alone, I could do whatever I damn well pleased. (Chapter 2)
-
Eliza’s sacrifice at Blackfriars Eliza’s leap is the apex of solidarity, transforming mentorship into guardianship. Her choice shields Nella and protects the unnamed women in the register, sealing their safety with her own peril and proving that mutual aid can carry a terrible, heroic cost.
Character Connections
The novel’s women form a chain of agency in which each link strengthens the next.
-
Nella Clavinger Betrayed by a man and physically diminished by her work, Nella channels both pain and expertise into service for other women. Her apothecary becomes a node in a shadow network, where knowledge substitutes for legal power and care becomes resistance.
-
Eliza Fanning Sent by her mistress, Mrs. Amwell, Eliza arrives as a courier and stays as a disciple. She translates awe into courage, learning to read danger and to act decisively; her final sacrifice epitomizes the theme’s highest expression: risking the self to protect the community.
-
Caroline Parcewell Caroline is the modern heir to this lineage, discovering that solidarity can cross time through story and evidence. As she pieces together the apothecary’s past, she reclaims the academic ambition she once abandoned, proving that historical empathy can catalyze present-tense liberation.
-
Lady Clarence Lady Clarence complicates the theme by seeking empowerment at another woman’s expense. Her commission violates Nella’s ethos, exposing how patriarchy can warp women into agents of one another’s harm and drawing a moral boundary around what true solidarity permits.
Symbolic Elements
-
The hidden apothecary shop Concealed behind a false wall, the shop is a secret commons—an architectural metaphor for underground power. Its concealment signals both the danger women face and the ingenuity with which they create protected spaces.
-
The register More than a ledger, the register is a counter-archive that preserves women’s names where official records will not. It binds individual acts into a collective narrative, making memory the medium of empowerment.
-
The bear vial The small blue vial etched with a bear threads past to present, placing Caroline’s hand directly on Nella’s world. As a found object, it literalizes discovery: solidarity begins when the past surfaces and asks to be recognized.
-
Poisons In a society that denies women lawful remedies, poisons operate as grim instruments of agency. Their moral ambiguity underscores the novel’s central tension: when justice is impossible, what forms of power remain—and at what cost?
Contemporary Relevance
The novel resonates with today’s ecosystems of female support—informal networks, mutual-aid groups, and digital communities where women warn, mentor, and testify. Caroline’s shift from a constraining marriage to self-directed scholarship mirrors ongoing conversations about labor, identity, and the right to one’s ambitions. The story’s insistence on collective remembrance echoes movements like #MeToo, where naming and recording harm becomes both protection for others and an assertion of presence. By honoring a hidden lineage, the book argues that solidarity isn’t merely comforting—it’s structurally transformative.
Essential Quote
"For many of these women," Nella whispered, "this may be the only place their names are recorded. The only place they will be remembered... The world is not kind to us... There are few places for a woman to leave an indelible mark." (Chapter 15)
This line crystallizes the theme by redefining empowerment as preservation and witness. Nella’s register gives women the dignity of being seen and remembered, transforming secrecy into legacy. The quote also foreshadows the novel’s cross-temporal arc: because their names endure, Caroline can find them—and, in finding them, find herself.