Alternative Faith and Spirituality
What This Theme Explores: The Book of Longings delves into the tension between rigid, patriarchal religious institutions and a more personal, inclusive spirituality. It critiques the exclusionary practices of first-century Judaism and early Christianity, advocating for a faith rooted in individual experience, direct connection to the divine, and recognition of the sacred feminine. This theme isn't about rejecting faith, but reimagining it to create space for silenced voices and suppressed truths, suggesting that true spiritual authority comes from within, not from external institutions.
Development of Alternative Faith
Ana's spiritual journey begins in secret rebellion against the patriarchal constraints of her society, evolving into active participation in a spiritual practice that honors her inner life. This progression is marked by key encounters and experiences that broaden her understanding of the divine.
Initially, Ana's spiritual life is confined to private acts of defiance. Her aunt, Yaltha, introduces her to alternative spiritual practices from Alexandria, most notably the incantation bowl. This marks Ana's first step toward a faith that values her personal longings as sacred.
Marriage to Jesus exposes Ana to a different form of alternative spirituality. Jesus reinterprets Jewish law through radical compassion, challenging the Temple priests' authority and emphasizing a direct, intimate relationship with God, whom he calls Abba. Their shared belief that God can be found within oneself, not just in holy places, solidifies their spiritual partnership.
Fleeing to Egypt, Ana finds a physical home for her spiritual beliefs among the Therapeutae. This community of Jewish philosophers offers a fully realized alternative to mainstream religion, where women are equals, study is paramount, and the divine feminine, Sophia, is openly worshipped. This validates and deepens Ana's spiritual path.
After Jesus's death, Ana returns to the Therapeutae, becoming its leader. Her ultimate spiritual act is creating her own sacred texts, including her hymn, "Thunder: Perfect Mind." She transcends being a follower of an alternative faith to become a creator, ensuring her spiritual voice, and the voices of other women, are preserved.
Key Examples
-
The Incantation Bowl: Yaltha introduces this as a tool for women's prayer, a practice outside the formal, male-dominated rituals of the synagogue. She tells Ana that while a man's holy of holies contains laws, a woman's contains longings. This redefines female desire as sacred. Ana's prayer in the bowl is a direct appeal to have her creative spirit blessed:
Lord our God, hear my prayer, the prayer of my hea. Bless the largeness inside me, no maer how I fear it. Bless my rd pens and my inks. Bless the ords I write. May they be beautiful in your sight. May they be visible to eyes not yet born. When I am dust, sing these ords oer my bones: she was a oice.
This act, detailed in the Chapter 1-5 Summary, is a foundational moment of Ana claiming her own spiritual authority.
-
The Therapeutae and Sophia: Yaltha’s stories of the Therapeutae present a radical alternative to Ana's world. This community practices a faith where women are leaders and scholars, and they pray to God's female spirit, Sophia. This revelation opens a new spiritual dimension for Ana, one that is explicitly feminist and inclusive. Yaltha explains, "As many women dwell there as men and they bear the same zeal and purpose. They’re even led by a woman, Skepsis, and there’s a great reverence for God’s female spirit. We prayed to her by her Greek name, Sophia."
-
Jesus’s Radical Teachings: Jesus consistently challenges the religious establishment. He calls God Abba (Father), a term of shocking intimacy. He tells Ana that God's kingdom is not just a future event but a reality "inside us." His willingness to associate with outcasts and disregard purity laws in favor of compassion represents a profound spiritual alternative to the legalism of the Pharisees and the corruption of the Temple priests.
-
"Thunder: Perfect Mind": Ana’s composition of this hymn is the culmination of her spiritual journey. The text, a real Gnostic poem, embraces paradox and rejects simple binaries ("I am the whore and the holy woman"). It represents a complex, non-dualistic spirituality that transcends the rigid categories of conventional religion, giving voice to a powerful and untamed divine feminine.
Character Connections
Ana's entire journey is a search for a spiritual path that doesn't require her to diminish herself. She moves from secretly writing stories of matriarchs to openly praying for her "largeness" to eventually leading a spiritual community and authoring her own sacred texts. Her faith is defined by her longing to be a voice.
Yaltha is the catalyst for Ana's spiritual awakening. Having been exiled from her home and faith community, she embodies a spirituality forged in suffering and wisdom. She introduces Ana to the concepts of the divine feminine, women's spiritual communities, and the sacredness of personal longing, acting as a guide to a world of faith beyond patriarchal constraints.
Jesus represents an alternative spirituality that emerges from within Judaism itself. He is not trying to create a new religion but to recall his own to its core principles of love and compassion. His personal, intimate relationship with God and his focus on inner transformation rather than external ritual align perfectly with Ana's own spiritual inclinations, forming the basis of their egalitarian partnership, a theme explored in Love as an Egalitarian Partnership.
Symbolism
The incantation bowl symbolizes a personalized, feminine spirituality. Unlike the official scrolls of the Torah, which contain laws written by men, the bowl is a vessel for a woman's most secret prayers and longings. It represents a direct, unmediated connection to the divine that bypasses official religious structures.
The Therapeutae community symbolizes a tangible alternative to the patriarchal societies of Galilee and Judea. It is a physical place where the spiritual ideals Ana longs for—equality, scholarship, and reverence for the feminine—are lived out daily. It is both a refuge and a spiritual destination.
Sophia, the Greek name for wisdom, symbolizes the divine feminine, or God's female spirit, that has been suppressed or ignored by patriarchal religion. Her worship by the Therapeutae represents the recovery of a more whole and balanced understanding of God, one that is central to the novel's alternative faith.
Contemporary Relevance
The novel's exploration of alternative faith resonates deeply today, as many feel alienated from traditional organized religion. The distinction between being "spiritual but not religious" mirrors Ana's journey. Her search for a faith that honors her intellect, creativity, and womanhood reflects ongoing efforts by feminist theologians to challenge patriarchal structures within major world religions. The novel's emphasis on the divine feminine and personal experience speaks to a widespread modern hunger for a spirituality that is more inclusive, personal, and empowering than the doctrines offered by many established institutions.