What This Theme Explores
Identity and Self-Discovery asks how we become who we are—and what happens when the roles we perform no longer fit. The novel suggests identity is not a single, stable essence but a collage of versions: who we were, who we perform, and who we might yet be. Grief, scandal, illness, and desire pry open the gap between public persona and private truth, forcing the characters to reassemble themselves with greater honesty. The question isn’t whether identity changes, but whether you choose how it changes.
How It Develops
At the outset, Hollis Shaw hosts the Five-Star Weekend as a polished, grieving widow whose brand-perfect life hides a hollow center. She invites friends who represent her past and present selves: Dru-Ann Jones, a high-powered agent under public siege; Tatum McKenzie, a Nantucket local still nursing old wounds; Brooke Kirtley, a Wellesley mom searching for a self beyond marriage; and Gigi Ling, an enigmatic online friend. Each woman arrives clinging to the safety of her narrative—successful, loyal, resilient, desirable—until the weekend exposes what those labels obscure.
As the island gathering intensifies, the event becomes a crucible. Hollis reconnects with Jack Finigan, confronting the version of herself she sidelined when she married, and the rift with Tatum that never healed. Meanwhile, the documentary interviews led by Caroline Shaw-Madden force the women to give language to their histories; in speaking their stories aloud, they hear the gaps and evasions. Secrets surface, facades crack, and the women begin to replace performance with confession—Gigi’s carefully crafted persona falters, Dru-Ann’s invincible armor dents, and Brooke’s attraction refuses to be dismissed as a phase.
By weekend’s end—and in the Epilogue—this reckoning becomes reconstruction. Hollis chooses a life rooted in her Nantucket self rather than in grief’s shadow; Brooke claims her queerness with joy, not apology; Tatum and Dru-Ann reframe the past to make room for a future; Gigi sheds the lie that has been defining her; and Caroline reframes her mother not as a brand but as a person. Identity, newly plural and self-directed, becomes a choice rather than a disguise.
Key Examples
-
Hollis’s return to her past self: Introduced through her “Hungry with Hollis” brand in the Prologue, Hollis clings to a public identity that keeps her functioning but numb. Reconnecting with Jack in the Round Room punctures that persona, anchoring her in a memory of uncurated love and reminding her that authenticity once came easily.
“When things were bad with Matthew, I would check up on you. I’d stalk your Facebook page. I did it when I was feeling low and I wanted to remember what it felt like to be really loved.”
-
Caroline’s discovery of her mother’s complexity: Caroline begins by filming a caricature—a “Cooking Kardashian”—and ends up documenting a woman with grit, skills, and a history that predate the brand. Jack’s testimony reframes Hollis not as an influencer but as a person who once scalloped and hunted, expanding Caroline’s understanding of how many selves a life can contain.
“I can’t believe my mom knows how to hunt and scallop,” she says. “It sounds like she used to be a completely different person.”
Jack chuckles. “You can be more than one kind of person in your life,” he says. “But I’ve always been a person who loves Hollis Shaw.” -
Brooke’s sexual awakening: Years of feeling miscast in marriage culminate in a tender, clarifying kiss and a public declaration on the deck of the Endeavor, as detailed in the Chapter 41-45 Summary. The scene shifts her from secrecy to self-definition; claiming her desire becomes the keystone that reorganizes every other role she plays.
-
Tatum’s confession about the softball game: In the Chapter 26-30 Summary, Tatum admits she threw the state championship, exposing the shame that calcified into resentment. Naming the truth dissolves the identity of “the one left behind,” allowing her to choose reconciliation over the old narrative of betrayal.
Character Connections
Hollis anchors the theme: grief splinters her life into before and after, and she tries to paste the halves together with a party. Hosting becomes an act of self-assembly—gathering the people who once knew her to see if their memories can help her remember herself. Her choice to embrace the island and refuse the role of “Matthew’s wife” marks identity as a decision, not a default.
Tatum embodies a self written by place and past. Her resentment has been identity’s armor; the moment she narrates the softball secret differently, the armor loosens. She doesn’t abandon her Nantucket self—she reinterprets it, proving that loyalty to home need not mean loyalty to pain.
Dru-Ann personifies the peril of equating self with success. When public condemnation guts her brand, the private woman—capable of contrition, connection, and repair—emerges. Her reconciliation with Tatum and her openness with friends signal a shift from invulnerability to integrity.
Brooke dramatizes late-in-life self-recognition. For years she performs wife and mother with diligence but without resonance; the weekend gives her permission to revise the script. Her coming out is not only romantic but existential—she chooses coherence over approval.
Gigi illustrates the risk of living behind a mask. Her constructed online persona and hidden affair create a version of self sustained by secrecy; when the lie collapses, she loses a storyline but gains reality. The novel frames this unmasking as painful but necessary—truth as the precondition for any durable identity.
Caroline functions as both witness and participant. Pointing a camera at others teaches her to see past surfaces, a skill she begins to apply at home. In re-editing her image of her mother, she quietly edits her own, moving from daughter-as-audience to woman-with-a-voice.
Symbolic Elements
The Five-Star Weekend itself symbolizes a curated pathway to the truth—an itinerary that promises control but delivers revelation. By organizing her friends from different life “eras,” Hollis tries to splice her identities together; the weekend’s unscripted collisions show that integration requires honesty, not choreography.
Nantucket stands for the self beneath performance—the landscape of memory, muscle, and belonging. Choosing the island is a homecoming not only to place but to a more elemental version of Hollis, signaling that authenticity feels like remembering.
The “Twist” guesthouse, a renovated childhood cottage, embodies past-made-new. Its very name signals reversal and surprise; it becomes a stage for pivots and second chances, including Dru-Ann’s change in fortune in the Chapter 46-50 Summary. The house insists that history isn’t something to escape, but something to rework.
Contemporary Relevance
In an age of feeds and filters, the novel’s insistence that identity is negotiated in private, not performed in public, feels bracing. Hollis’s “Hungry with Hollis” persona mirrors a culture where branding can numb grief and flatten complexity, while Dru-Ann’s ordeal echoes the volatility of reputation in digital spaces. The story validates late-in-life reinvention—romantic, professional, or personal—pushing back against scripts that claim we’re fully formed by midlife. It also argues for analog repair: old friends, shared meals, and unedited conversations as antidotes to the curated self.
Essential Quote
“You can be more than one kind of person in your life.”
This line distills the novel’s ethical invitation: treat identity as an evolving practice rather than a verdict. It legitimizes reinvention without erasing history, granting the characters—and readers—permission to grow beyond the roles that once kept them safe.