What This Theme Explores
The Influence of the Past examines how memory, loss, and formative bonds continue to script the present, whether we admit it or not. For Hollis Shaw, the weekend is less a party than a structured reckoning with history—an experiment in whether old selves and old loves can coexist with who she is now. The novel probes the difference between honoring the past and being trapped by it, asking what it takes to turn nostalgia and regret into insight. It argues that only by integrating painful truths—about marriage, friendship, and identity—can the characters write a more honest future.
How It Develops
At the outset, the past is both salve and wound. Hollis’s decision to create a Five-Star Weekend grows out of grief for Matthew Madden and the earlier loss of her mother, and it exposes the seam between her Nantucket upbringing and her glossy, “summer person” life. Even Hollis’s private Facebook surveillance of Jack Finigan signals how easily old attachments infiltrate the present (Chapter 1-5 Summary).
As friends from each life chapter arrive—Tatum McKenzie, Dru-Ann Jones, and Brooke Kirtley—history becomes active, not archival. Long-simmering tensions flare (particularly between Tatum and Dru-Ann), and Jack’s unexpected return moves the theme from subtext to text, confronting Hollis with the road not taken (Chapter 11-15 Summary). Midway revelations—like Tatum’s secret about the state championship and her fear of repeating her mother’s illness—show how old choices and inherited anxieties script current behavior (Chapter 26-30 Summary).
By the end, confrontation turns into integration. Tatum and Dru-Ann reach genuine forgiveness during their sail on the Endeavor (Chapter 41-45 Summary). Hollis and Jack revisit the Round Room to translate adolescent longing into adult closure—and possibility (Chapter 36-40 Summary). The revelation of Matthew’s affair with Gigi Ling forces Hollis to reconcile the marriage she lived with the marriage that was, and her decision to forgive demonstrates growth rather than denial. In the Epilogue, choosing to return to Nantucket makes literal the novel’s thesis: the past doesn’t vanish; it’s folded into a more truthful present.
Key Examples
-
The Five-Star Weekend itself is a ritualized excavation of the past. By curating one friend from each era, Hollis constructs a living timeline and tests whether the selves attached to each chapter can speak to one another. The gathering becomes therapy by design: a setting where memory is invited to correct, complicate, and heal the present.
-
Hollis and Jack’s reunion shows the past’s romantic gravitational pull. What begins as digital lurking culminates in a return to the Round Room, where their shared history instantly restores intimacy that time had only paused. The scene reframes first love not as a trap but as a reference point—useful for measuring what Hollis wants now.
-
Tatum’s fear and resentments dramatize how unprocessed history governs the present. Her panic about a breast lump is amplified by her mother’s fate, while the decades-old hurt over Hollis becoming a “summer person” and her rancor toward Dru-Ann keep her stuck in adolescent hierarchies. The confession about throwing the state championship reveals a single choice echoing across 35 years, distorting friendship until it’s finally faced (Chapter 26-30 Summary).
-
Gigi’s hidden affair with Matthew makes the past an explosive, present-tense event. Her “hiding in plain sight” during the weekend layers every interaction with dread and duplicity, culminating in a truth that collides with Hollis’s grief. The revelation hurts, but it also clears space for a less sentimental, more grounded understanding of love and loyalty (Chapter 41-45 Summary).
Character Connections
Hollis is the novel’s integrator. She tries to harmonize being Tom Shaw’s daughter and a Nantucket local with her reinvention as a Wellesley lifestyle figure. Confronting her marriage to Matthew, her unresolved feelings for Jack, and her evolving friendships becomes a single project: learning who she is without the illusions that once protected her.
Tatum embodies entrapment by memory. Her identity is guarded by old grievances—against Hollis for “leaving,” against Dru-Ann for classist slights—and by inherited fear. Her arc converts vigilance into vulnerability: once she speaks what she’s hidden, the past stops policing her present.
Dru-Ann represents accountability to one’s former self. Called out for the jokes and attitudes she once considered harmless, she must recognize that words can have a long afterlife. Her apology on the Endeavor is not mere closure; it’s a redefinition of strength as the willingness to own harm and change.
Jack functions as a counterfactual made flesh. His arrival lets Hollis test an alternate life path without fantasy’s haze. Rather than rescuing her, he helps her see the distance between adolescent passion and adult choice, making any future together an act of clarity, not escape.
Symbolic Elements
The Twist, Hollis’s childhood cottage-turned-guesthouse, symbolizes continuity through reinvention. It sits beside her luxurious home like a footnote that is actually the thesis, reminding Hollis (and us) that humble origins don’t disappear—they inform what “success” means. Even the Chubby Checker record literalizes the “twist” of time: the past replays, but in new grooves.
The Round Room is a sanctuary of memory where feeling outlasts chronology. Returning there transforms teenage secrecy into adult honesty; it’s not a time machine but a mirror that shows continuity and change at once.
Hollis’s playlists operate as portable archives. Songs collapse decades into a single feeling, demonstrating how art stores emotional truth and turns recollection into communal experience.
First Light, the main house, balances hope with rootedness. Its name gestures toward beginnings, yet the foundation is inherited land—an image of the novel’s ethic: start anew, but stand on what made you.
Contemporary Relevance
In an era when social media preserves our histories in searchable form, the past is never truly past. Hollis’s ability to track Jack online is a distinctly modern temptation, keeping dormant relationships in constant, curated view. The Five-Star Weekend mirrors the way people now montage their lives—highlight reels stitched from old circles—then must manage the messy reality when those edits collide. The novel offers a counterpoint to digital nostalgia: use the archive to tell the truth, not to relive a fantasy.
Essential Quote
"I wanted to be surrounded by the people who knew me best, Moira wrote, even though a couple of the women I hadn’t seen or talked to in years. ... I wanted to celebrate the friendships that had made me who I was."
This credo articulates the novel’s argument that identity is relational and cumulative—made by people we’ve been with across time, not just choices we make alone. It reframes reunion as an act of self-knowledge: inviting the past in, not to replay it, but to understand the person it created.