What This Theme Explores
Communication and Silence probes how people seek to be known when words fail, are forbidden, or would endanger those they love. The novel asks when silence functions as care and when it becomes complicity, and how shame and trauma choke truth across decades. It widens “voice” beyond speech—gesture, technology, ritual, and action carry meaning—while showing that silencing, whether imposed by a regime or by family habit, extracts a generational cost. Ultimately, it tests whether love can cross the gaps created by fear, time, and the “things we cannot say.”
How It Develops
In the past timeline, village innocence gives way to secrecy. Early on, Alina Dziak dreams openly with Tomasz Slaski, but her parents’ protective quiet around politics keeps her naïve. The Nazi occupation turns discretion into survival: whispers replace plans, messages are hidden in cellars, and even truth between lovers becomes dangerous. What begins as loving omission hardens into enforced muteness; as violence escalates, silence stops being a choice.
The present timeline begins in a different kind of quiet: Alice Michaels struggles to interpret her nonverbal son, Eddie Michaels, while skirting hard conversations with her husband, Wade. When Alina—now Babcia—suffers a stroke, she joins Eddie in wordless isolation, and the family must rely on an AAC app to bridge the void. Babcia’s fractured plea propels Alice to Poland, where past and present converge; what the war silenced must finally be spoken. The novel’s arcs meet when Emilia’s testimony completes Tomasz’s unfinished message, allowing the truth to surface and teaching Alice to practice a braver, more explicit honesty at home.
Key Examples
-
Eddie’s Meltdown in the Prologue: Eddie’s explosive reaction to a small change is not chaos but clarity—his body broadcasts a message his mouth cannot. The scene reframes “behavior” as communication, urging Alice (and readers) to listen to nonverbal cues with the same respect given to speech.
-
Babcia Uses the AAC App: After her stroke, Babcia’s painstaking taps forge a bridge between generations who share the same communicative barrier. The app turns silence from a prison into a corridor, transforming a final wish—“Find Tomasz”—into a mission that reorganizes the family’s past and present.
-
Aleksy Slaski’s Execution in the Chapter 6-10 Summary: The Nazis wield murder as a public statement, converting a body into a billboard of terror. The town’s subsequent hush shows how violence can colonize language itself, teaching entire communities to swallow dissent.
-
Tomasz’s Confession in the Chapter 11-15 Summary: Weeks of silence curdle into shame as Tomasz withholds his Wehrmacht service; when he finally speaks, the truth wounds but also repairs. His disclosure models how confession, though dangerous, can create intimacy strong enough to outlast suspicion.
-
The Final Revelation in the Chapter 36-40 Summary: Emilia’s account breaks decades of misapprehension, translating sacrifice into understanding. By voicing what the dead and traumatized could not, she releases Babcia from the burden of secrecy and Alice from inherited confusion.
Character Connections
Alice Michaels learns that listening is an ethical act. Parenting Eddie trains her to translate patterns, gestures, and silence; decoding Babcia’s halting messages extends that skill to history itself. The same attentiveness she applies to the app becomes the courage she uses with Wade, as she replaces avoidance with explicit needs and boundaries.
Alina Dziak (Babcia) carries a lifetime of unsaid truths. Wartime secrecy saves lives but seeds a future built on omissions; emigration and reinvention require more quiet. Her stroke literalizes the theme by trapping her voice inside her body—yet the urgency of her final request reveals that truth, even belated, is a form of love.
Eddie Michaels embodies communication beyond speech. His meltdowns, routines, and later AAC choices insist that meaning lives in rhythm and symbol, not just in sentences. His bond with Babcia proves that mutual recognition can happen in shared silence, provided someone is willing to learn the language.
Tomasz Slaski communicates most powerfully through action. His work in resistance, his risky return, and his ultimate sacrifice are arguments in deeds; his late confession shows that words still matter, especially when they carry shame. Together, his actions and admissions teach that love must be both done and said.
Symbolic Elements
The AAC App symbolizes voice as a human right rather than a talent. It renders the invisible visible, converting interior experience into sharable language and insisting that technology can be a moral instrument when it amplifies the unheard.
The Hidden Cellar embodies the double edge of secrecy. It shelters bodies and conversations, but it also normalizes concealment; what protects can also distort, turning truth into contraband even after danger passes.
Letters are bridges that sometimes fail. The early exchanges between Alina and Tomasz carry tender transparency; the unanswered letters Babcia later sends to Emilia represent grief trapped mid-crossing—a message forever en route.
The Dreidel stands for wordless solidarity. Passed between mothers, it becomes a tactile lexicon Eddie can use to self-soothe and signal needs, proving that shared objects can carry empathy across silence.
Contemporary Relevance
The novel speaks to families negotiating neurodiversity, where the labor of understanding demands patience, tools, and humility. It also illuminates how unvoiced trauma—whether from war, migration, or domestic strain—cascades through generations until someone chooses disclosure over protection. In a polarized public sphere, its warning about silencing dissent is stark: power controls narratives first and people second. By honoring alternative communication and urging courageous speech, the book argues for communities that make room for every kind of voice.
Essential Quote
“Babcia scared, Babcia types.
Eddie scared, Eddie types.
Eddie...is...okay, Babcia slowly pecks out. Babcia...is...okay.”
This exchange distills the theme: technology mediates a dialogue between two people who cannot speak, turning fear into reassurance. The parallel sentences enact mutual recognition—each naming the other’s feeling—and show how even painstaking, fragmented language can heal when it is finally shared.