What This Theme Explores
Grief and Loss in The Story of Edgar Sawtelle asks what happens when sorrow becomes the engine of a life—how absence remakes identity, bends loyalty, and warps love. The novel widens grief beyond death to include the loss of voice, home, innocence, and legacy, tracing how these absences reverberate across generations and even species. For Edgar Sawtelle, grief becomes both a secret language and a prison, while the Sawtelle dogs absorb and mirror the family’s pain with a stark, instinctive clarity. The book ultimately interrogates whether grief can be expressed, contained, or transformed—or whether, left unmet, it spirals into betrayal, exile, and ruin.
How It Develops
Loss stains the Sawtelle story before Edgar’s birth. In the novel’s opening movement, Trudy Sawtelle suffers miscarriages and a stillbirth that she later names a “black seed”—an image of grief taking root in the family’s soil. The fleeting hope of the wolf pup that Gar rescues, only to lose overnight, turns the farm’s south field into a sanctuary of absence. From the outset, the family’s drive for wholeness is born from a history of things that cannot be kept.
That early ache deepens into catastrophe with the death of Gar Sawtelle. The household fractures, and grief differentiates itself in the people who remain. Edgar’s muteness makes mourning a bodily ordeal—a pressure he cannot voice that curdles into suspicion and purpose. Trudy’s sorrow is braced by survival; she clings to the routines of the kennel and to Claude Sawtelle, whose presence promises stability even as it courts danger. For Almondine, grief is simple and absolute: the house still smells like Gar, the floors still tremble with him; her devotion becomes a search that cannot end.
In the middle sections, grief sheds the homestead and steps into wilderness. Edgar’s flight into the Chequamegon forest turns bereavement into exile; his unresolved sorrow seeks justice and edges toward revenge. That escape severs him from his mother and, most searingly, from Almondine, transforming private mourning into mutual abandonment. The novel shows grief as centrifugal—spinning people away from the very bonds they need to survive it.
By the end, grief becomes annihilating. In the final descent, Doctor Papineau, Edgar, and Claude die in rapid succession, and the barn fire erases the kennel and its meticulous records, incinerating the Sawtelles’ past and foreclosing their future. Almondine’s death on the road, still searching for Edgar, is the last tenderness twisted into tragedy. The book closes not with healing, but with the stark ledger of what grief—unspoken, unmet—can destroy.
Key Examples
-
Trudy’s Stillbirth:
He found her in the bathroom huddled in the claw-footed tub. In her arms she held a perfectly formed baby boy, his skin like blue wax. Whatever had happened had happened quickly, with little pain, and though she shook as if crying, she was silent. The only sound was the damp suck of her skin against the white porcelain. This scene establishes grief as quiet, visceral, and isolating. The “blue wax” stillness and the silence in the bathroom prefigure Edgar’s later muteness, suggesting from the first pages that pain in this family arrives wordless and total.
-
Gar’s Death and Edgar’s Silent Scream:
His heart surged in his chest. He tried to force sound from his mouth, but there was only the gasp of exhaled breath. He swung his hand wide, then struck his chest with all the force he could muster, mouthing the words. “Is this an emergency?” the operator said. He struck his chest again. Again. Each blow drove a single note from his body. “A-n-a-a-a.” Edgar’s inability to speak literalizes grief’s chokehold: mourning collapses language into impact, sound into a single note of pain. The scene transforms a son’s discovery into a lifelong wound and sets his path toward suspicion, self-blame, and vengeance.
-
The Funeral: The procession of families and Sawtelle dogs reframes Gar’s death as a communal bereavement. The gathered animals and handlers testify to a life’s work suddenly unmoored, amplifying the loss from household tragedy to a ruptured legacy.
-
Almondine’s Search:
He was gone, she knew this, but something of him clung to the baseboards. At times the floor quivered under his footstep. She stood then and nosed into the kitchen and the bathroom and the bedroom—especially the closet—her intention to press her ruff against his hand, run it along his thigh, feel the heat of his body through the fabric. Almondine’s sensory fidelity—smell, vibration, remembered touch—renders grief as presence that refuses to admit absence. Her searching becomes a portrait of loyalty that outlasts understanding, and of love that keeps moving after its object has vanished.
-
Edgar’s Dreams: In exile, Edgar dreams of his father, dreams that blur guidance with accusation. These visitations keep grief active, binding him to the past and pushing him toward a fateful confrontation he cannot release or fully explain.
Character Connections
Edgar Sawtelle: Edgar’s grief is both his private language and his undoing. His muteness forces him to feel before he can narrate, and that pressure turns sorrow into obsession—first to name the truth of Gar’s death, then to balance its scales. His coming-of-age—his moral and emotional apprenticeship—unfolds as a Coming of Age and Loss of Innocence shaped by grief that he can neither voice nor escape.
Trudy Sawtelle: Trudy’s early losses forge a fierce, pragmatic love that holds the kennel together after Gar’s death. Her bond with Claude functions as survival and self-betrayal at once, a way to stave off collapse that deepens the family’s peril. She embodies grief as endurance—tending to the living while haunted by what cannot be restored.
Claude Sawtelle: Claude’s grief is corrosive, rooted in exclusion and envy—his own sense of being sidelined in the Sawtelle Family and Legacy. His response to loss is acquisition: to fill his emptiness with control. In him, grief curdles into ambition, turning mourning into a grab for place, power, and, ultimately, possession of the farm itself.
Almondine: As a nonhuman mourner, Almondine reveals grief stripped of rationalization. Her fidelity to Gar, and later her searching for Edgar, expresses the Human-Animal Bond as an enduring contract that persists beyond death and distance. In her final journey, love’s persistence becomes its own form of tragedy.
Symbolic Elements
-
The Birch Grove Crosses: The small grove in the south field, holding the graves of the stillborn baby, the wolf pup, Gar, and Almondine, is the farm’s map of absence. It turns private sorrow into a landscape, marking how loss accumulates until it becomes a place you can stand.
-
The Barn Fire: The blaze that destroys the kennel doesn’t just level buildings; it incinerates the breeding records—the family’s proof of purpose. By erasing what was meticulously kept, the fire makes legacy itself combustible, the last and largest thing grief consumes.
-
Silence: Edgar’s muteness symbolizes grief’s inexpressibility—the way pain resists language and isolates the mourner. His “silent scream” becomes the novel’s emblem: a body trying to speak what voice cannot carry.
-
Gar’s Ghost: The apparition in the rain externalizes Edgar’s unresolved mourning—longing, guilt, and doubt embodied. Whether specter or projection, it shows how the dead inhabit the living when death is sudden, suspicious, and unatoned.
Contemporary Relevance
Wroblewski’s portrait of complicated grief—knotted with guilt, anger, and longing—mirrors modern understandings that mourning rarely moves in tidy stages. The novel challenges the pressure to “move on,” insisting instead on the slow, nonlinear work of living with loss. It also honors those whose pain is hard to voice—because of disability, trauma, or culture—by showing how empathy, patience, and alternate forms of expression can be lifelines. In a world of fractured communities and inherited wounds, the book feels urgent: unattended grief does not fade; it spreads.
Essential Quote
He tried to force sound from his mouth, but there was only the gasp of exhaled breath... Each blow drove a single note from his body. “A-n-a-a-a.”
This moment distills the theme: grief overwhelms language, compressing a life-shattering event into a raw, bodily signal. Edgar’s single note is both a cry and a failure to cry, capturing how mourning traps him inside himself and sets the tragic trajectory of the story.