Honesty and Communication
What This Theme Explores
Crenshaw probes the fragile balance between shielding loved ones from pain and telling the truth so trust can grow. As Jackson watches his family’s finances unravel, Mom and Dad use jokes and euphemisms to “protect” him, but their silence leaves him more anxious and alone. The book asks whether kindness without honesty is really kindness at all—and whether children are stronger partners when given facts rather than fairy tales. Through the arrival of Crenshaw, the story argues that clear, age-appropriate truth-telling becomes a source of dignity, resilience, and connection.
How It Develops
At first, the family’s strategy is to minimize the crisis with humor. Jackson sees overdue bills and hears arguments through doors, yet his parents offer cheery reassurances about “money trees,” pushing him into a role of quiet watcher who collects data but receives no answers. The imaginary cat appears precisely in that pressure zone: Crenshaw insists on “the facts,” a nudge that exposes how the family’s silence has trained Jackson to lie gently too—he even tells Robin that everything is fine, perpetuating the very opacity that frightens him (Chapter 16-20 Summary).
A flashback reveals that this pattern of avoidance is old, not new. During their first bout of homelessness, Jackson’s parents renamed living in a minivan “car camping” (Chapter 21-25 Summary) and told him he would “understand when you’re older” (recalled in Chapter 16-20 Summary). The renaming softened the blow, but it also taught Jackson that real questions bring deflection rather than dialogue.
When their situation worsens, Jackson refuses to be a spectator. He writes a runaway note that lists “the facts,” a document that turns his need for truth into an ultimatum and compels a family confrontation (Chapter 46-50 Summary). For the first time, his parents acknowledge that secrecy has harmed their children and promise a new norm: as much honesty as they can manage, together.
Key Examples
-
Discomfort with “hard questions”: After an expensive vet visit, Jackson asks directly if they have enough money, and his parents pivot to euphemisms about being “financially challenged.”
“I didn’t ask any more hard questions after that… Somehow I just knew my parents didn’t want to give me hard answers.”
(Chapter 6-10 Summary)
This scene sets the pattern: humor becomes a guardrail that keeps truth out—and Jackson in the dark—teaching him that inquiry risks rejection. -
Crenshaw as the voice of truth:
“The facts. You need to tell the truth, my friend.”
Crenshaw names what no one else will: the family’s survival depends on naming reality. By urging Jackson to start with himself, the cat reframes honesty as an inner posture before it becomes a conversation with others (recounted in Chapter 16-20 Summary). -
The runaway note as a demand for clarity:
“Dear Mom and Dad, Here are the facts… I am old enough to understand things.”
Jackson adopts the language he trusts—facts—to puncture the fog of euphemism. The note’s starkness jolts his parents into recognizing that silence is not protection but harm (Chapter 46-50 Summary). -
The family’s breakthrough:
“Starting today, we’ll be as honest with you as we can… ‘It’s a deal.’”
Their pact replaces secrecy with partnership. Honesty becomes a shared tool for facing instability rather than a burden to be dodged (see Chapter 46-50 Summary).
Character Connections
Jackson gravitates toward science and “facts,” so euphemism feels like betrayal. His arc is a movement from passive observation to principled insistence: he learns that asking hard questions—and risking discomfort—is an act of care, not disloyalty.
Jackson’s parents are loving, resourceful, and terrified. They equate optimism with safety, but their conflict in Chapter 11-15 Summary shows how fear of failure stifles their ability to ask for help and to speak plainly. The novel complicates blame: their avoidance is a coping strategy with real costs, especially for their children’s sense of security.
Crenshaw externalizes what Jackson cannot yet say aloud. As an imaginary friend, he can interrupt avoidance with humor and tenderness, modeling the courage to speak the unspeakable and pushing Jackson toward authentic conversation rather than escape.
Marisol embodies honest, nonjudgmental listening. When Jackson confides in her about his family and about Crenshaw, her easy acceptance proves that truth can open doors to empathy instead of pity, reinforcing his resolve to be candid (Chapter 41-45 Summary).
Symbolic Elements
Crenshaw: The giant cat is the “truth in the room”—impossible to ignore, playful yet insistent. His size and timing suggest that unspoken realities grow until they demand attention, and that naming them can be both scary and relieving.
Whispering and closed doors: Repeated overheard arguments mark the boundary between adult truth and child exclusion. The barrier symbolizes how secrecy magnifies fear; what’s concealed becomes more ominous than what’s explained.
The runaway note: A paper “ledger” of facts, the note transforms emotion into evidence. It symbolizes Jackson’s shift from silent anxiety to accountable dialogue—truth made concrete and unavoidable.
Contemporary Relevance
Families today often navigate job loss, medical debt, and housing precarity; Crenshaw insists that children deserve honest context for those pressures. Its handling of poverty and homelessness shows how secrecy compounds shame and mental strain, while age-appropriate candor builds agency and trust. In an era attentive to emotional literacy, the novel champions the idea that resilience grows not from denial but from clear-eyed conversation and shared problem-solving.
Essential Quote
“Starting today, we’ll be as honest with you as we can. Is that what you want?” … “All right, then,” said my dad. “It’s a deal.”
This promise converts honesty from a private wish into a family covenant. By framing truth-telling as a mutual commitment, the scene recasts communication as collective strength: naming hardship does not break the family—it binds them to face it together.