What This Theme Explores
Cultural Identity and Assimilation in The Only Good Indians probes what it costs to stay rooted in Blackfeet tradition while living inside a dominant white culture that misreads, commodifies, or erases Indigenous presence. The novel refuses a simple binary of “Indian” versus “white,” revealing identity as a performance shaped by pressure, guilt, and longing. It asks whether authenticity lies in preserving ritual unchanged or in adapting its spirit to new arenas of life. Ultimately, it argues that cultural identity survives not as a relic but as a living practice that must be continually made.
How It Develops
The theme emerges first with the men who left. In the early “runaways” movement, the narrative tracks the abrasions of assimilation in the world beyond the reservation, especially in Chapter 1-5 Summary. Richard Boss Ribs is reduced to stereotype on the oil fields, nicknamed and mythologized for white consumption, while Lewis Clarke tries to pass in Great Falls with his white wife, Peta. Both discover that leaving the rez doesn’t dissolve their past; it hollows it out and throws it back as a mask they must wear to be legible.
The second movement turns homeward to the people who stayed, in Chapter 6-10 Summary. On the reservation, Gabriel Cross Guns resists assimilation by doubling down on a warrior self-image—part armor, part parody—while Cassidy Sees Elk models a steadier, modern Blackfeet life not rooted in spectacle. Here, identity feels communal and grounded, but it is still complicated by history, scarcity, and the performative scripts the outside world imposes—and that insiders sometimes internalize.
Finally, the next generation reframes the question of belonging in Chapter 11-15 Summary. Denorah Cross Guns channels tradition into athletic excellence, turning the basketball court into a new ritual space that honors skill, lineage, and pride. Her confrontation with the avenging Elk Head Woman signals a pivot: rather than reenacting the cycles that trapped her elders, Denorah invents a way to carry the past forward without being consumed by it.
Key Examples
-
Ricky’s tokenism in the oil fields: Ricky is treated as a mascot whose “built-in” traits are imagined by white coworkers and used to justify exploitation. He draws on a warrior fantasy for strength, but the very fantasy reveals how he’s cornered between stereotype and survival—a performance he didn’t write but must inhabit.
-
Lewis’s assimilated life: Lewis’s suburban home—where even his graduation blanket becomes a point of quiet negotiation—shows how assimilation requires erasing visible markers of identity. His flattened accent and imagined headlines from back home expose a double alienation: he no longer sounds like “home,” yet he will never be fully accepted where he lives.
-
Performing “Indianness” on the phone: When Lewis calls his old friends, their banter about “Indian tacos” and his sliding back into a rez voice capture identity as something people consciously modulate. The ease of the performance is seductive, but it also underscores how fractured identity becomes when one’s audience dictates which self is welcome.
-
Denorah’s cultural synthesis: Denorah draws in a ledger-art style and dominates on the court, binding ancestor imagery to contemporary movement. Her victory over Elk Head Woman does not invoke old rites but new virtues—courage, empathy, and discipline—showing tradition’s spirit can thrive in modern forms.
Character Connections
Lewis Clarke exemplifies assimilation’s quiet damage. He trades proximity to community for the promise of stability, only to find that his “new” life requires constant self-erasure and secrecy—what he calls hiding his “tribal junk.” His guilt makes him spiritually exposed, the perfect vessel for the past to inhabit and punish.
Gabriel Cross Guns resists by performing a warrior persona, a rebellious script that both protects and endangers him. The swagger is a protest against being made small by America’s gaze, yet it locks him into a narrow, romanticized masculinity that can’t nourish him or the people he loves.
Denorah Cross Guns offers a generational answer. She refuses the false choice between tradition and modernity by making the court a ceremonial ground and her body a ledger page in motion. Her compassion at the climax reframes strength itself, suggesting that survival—and culture—depend on creative remaking rather than repetition.
Shaney Holds complicates the picture by exposing how “Indian” is flattened into a single category by outsiders. Pushed toward Lewis as a generic ethnic pairing, she becomes a mirror for his projections—intertribal difference, desire, fear—and, in his imagination, even morphs into the monstrous embodiment of the culture he betrayed. Her presence shows that assimilation doesn’t just blur identity; it distorts how people see one another within Native communities.
Symbolic Elements
Basketball: The sport is a contemporary proving ground for honor, stamina, and communal pride, echoing the role of past warrior traditions without reproducing their violence. For Denorah, each play becomes a mark of cultural continuity, translating heritage into motion and mastery.
Reservation vs. Off-Reservation: The rez embodies continuity and shared memory, but also scarcity and surveillance by history; the off-rez world promises mobility yet delivers isolation and stereotype. Moving between these spaces dramatizes how identity is policed by place—and how place can both protect and confine.
Lewis’s “tribal junk”: The hidden art and artifacts he tries to hang in his home are emblems of a self kept out of sight. Every negotiation over a wall or a blanket registers the compromises assimilation demands, turning décor into a map of psychic fracture.
The Thanksgiving Classic (the elk hunt): Intended as an act of provision tied to tradition, the hunt becomes a desecration when conducted with haste and disregard for sacred limits. Its aftermath creates a spiritual debt that haunts the men, embodying what happens when performance replaces reverence.
Contemporary Relevance
Jones’s portrait of cultural identity resonates widely: Indigenous sovereignty struggles continue under the weight of colonial narratives, while immigrant and diasporic communities face similar pressures to assimilate without losing themselves. The novel also critiques the demand for “authenticity,” exposing how stereotypes shape both external judgments and internal performances. In a social-media age that rewards curated selves, The Only Good Indians insists that identity is neither costume nor museum piece but a practice—imperfect, contextual, and ongoing.
Essential Quote
“Like he’s been doing for years, he imagines the headline on the Glacier Reporter back home: FORMER BASKETBALL STAR CAN’T EVEN HANG GRADUATION BLANKET IN OWN HOME.”
This imagined headline crystallizes Lewis’s double bind—mocked by the past he left and constrained by the present he entered. The small domestic detail (a blanket on a wall) becomes a measure of cultural permission, revealing how assimilation reduces heritage to décor and turns identity into something to be negotiated, apologized for, or hidden.