What This Theme Explores
The Cycle of Violence in The Only Good Indians asks how a single violation spirals into an ever-widening loop of harm—first bodily, then psychological, then communal. It probes what happens when guilt is left to harden into fate rather than softened by true atonement, and how retribution masquerades as justice while multiplying grief. The novel entwines natural law, cultural memory, and the supernatural to show violence as a self-sustaining system that feeds on fear, shame, and broken relationships. Crucially, it also asks whether empathy can interrupt that system and what it costs to choose repair over revenge.
How It Develops
The cycle begins with a rupture: the men’s “Thanksgiving Classic” slaughter in a forbidden place turns a hunt into desecration. That transgression doesn’t just break tribal codes and ecological balance; it creates a moral debt whose interest compounds across years. From that moment, the novel’s momentum is not simply “cause, then effect,” but the tightening of a noose—each attempt to forget or rationalize only winds the rope.
A decade later, Elk Head Woman embodies the past returning, fueled by revenge but operating through the men’s own vulnerabilities. She doesn’t merely strike; she reconfigures reality so that the perpetrators become the instruments of their own punishment. Moving from Lewis Clarke in town back to the reservation, she targets the bonds between Gabriel Cross Guns and Cassidy Sees Elk, turning friendship, fatherhood, and community ritual into sites of catastrophic mistrust.
The cycle threatens to cross generations—violence consumed by fathers poised to be inherited by their children. It’s here that the narrative finds its pivot in Denorah Cross Guns, who recognizes that ending the story requires stepping out of its script. Her choice reframes power not as the capacity to avenge, but as the courage to refuse the logic of harm, even when justified by loss.
Key Examples
-
The “Thanksgiving Classic”: The illegal killing of an elk herd in a sacred area replaces respectful hunting with spectacle, revealing the men’s eagerness to perform power rather than honor tradition. As detailed in the Chapter 11-15 Summary, this frenzy is the cycle’s ignition point: a single act that warps the natural and cultural order and demands an answer.
-
Ricky’s Death: The novel opens with the death of Richard Boss Ribs, which echoes both the supernatural penalty stalking the hunters and the systemic, real-world violence against Indigenous men. In the Chapter 1-5 Summary, his end situates the characters at the intersection of two cycles—one they unleashed, one they were born into—making “blame” and “escape” equally elusive.
-
The Sweat Lodge Massacre: By planting doubt and staging evidence, Elk Head Woman weaponizes grief, turning a space of purification into a killing ground. In the Chapter 26-30 Summary, Gabe and Cass destroy each other not because they are inherently murderous, but because the cycle has taught them to read every gesture as threat and every memory as accusation.
-
Denorah’s Choice: At the climax, Denorah refuses the story’s inherited ending when she shields the reborn calf and its mother. As shown in the Chapter 31 Summary, her act breaks the feedback loop: she recognizes mirrored grief and answers violation with protection, not retaliation.
Character Connections
Lewis, Gabe, Cass, and Ricky are the cycle’s first engine and its earliest casualties. Each man tries to outrun the past in his own way—assimilation, geographic escape, selective forgetting—but the dodge only deepens the cycle’s hold. Lewis’s unraveling shows the corrosion of guilt most starkly: his paranoia leads to killing Shaney Holds and to the death of Peta, proving that once violence is normalized, it seeps into domestic spaces and reframes love as risk.
Elk Head Woman is not just an avenger but the cycle given personality: she speaks in the grammar the men created. Her method—making them participate in their own ruin—lays bare the theme’s moral geometry: violence returns, altered and amplified, until the original actors cannot distinguish external attack from internal collapse.
Denorah Cross Guns stands where pattern meets possibility. As an athlete schooled in rules, restraint, and reading the play, she models a different response to pressure: recognition and redirect rather than strike back. Her compassion is not passivity but strategy—a culturally restorative choice that honors life and interrupts a story that otherwise would claim her, too.
Symbolic Elements
The Basketball Game: Basketball, especially in Denorah’s arc, counterpoints the chaos of the hunt with a conflict bound by rules, fairness, and clear outcomes. When the final confrontation echoes a game, the novel suggests another way to resolve tension: skill, respect, and the choice to pass rather than shoot.
The Mauser Rifle: Gabe’s inherited rifle functions as a lineage of harm—a “war trophy” that threads past conquest to present catastrophe. When it resurfaces in the men’s final conflict, it literalizes how old weapons—and the thinking they encode—keep firing across generations.
The “Thanksgiving Classic”: The nickname trivializes desecration, reframing atrocity as an inside joke. Its irony curdles over time, becoming the holiday no one wants: an annualized reminder that the celebration of harm will always demand another feast.
Contemporary Relevance
The novel’s cycle mirrors real patterns—gang retaliation, intimate-partner violence, and state-sanctioned harms—in which fear and honor codes perpetuate injury long after the initial act. It also resonates as an allegory of colonization’s afterlives: an original violation of land and people that keeps producing new losses until confronted differently. By elevating restorative impulses over punitive ones, the book advocates a model of justice that acknowledges pain, protects the vulnerable, and prizes future flourishing over past scorekeeping.
Essential Quote
She holds her right hand up the slope, palm out, fingers spread—the old man demonstrates—and she says it clear in that cold air: No, Dad! No!
This moment crystallizes the theme’s rupture: a child refuses to inherit a script written by her elders’ violence. The gesture—open palm, not clenched fist—turns power into protection and grief into guardianship. In a world where every harm has seemed to require an answering blow, Denorah’s “No” is the first, necessary “Yes” to another way of living.